2. foreign minister and a member of the VMRO-DPMNE party, justified their claims Skopje 2014, Skopje, North by stating in 2010: “Alexander the Great, in fact, had no passport or birth certificate. Macedonia (photo: B. Bakal, 2022) We all live in a geographic area where we share a common past, but our attitude Skopje 2014, Skopje, Sjeverna towards history is inclusive. That of the Greeks is exclusive.”13 Makedonija, 2014. The Macedonian right-wing government aimed at creating a Macedonian na- tional identity amidst the competing neighbouring agendas, and regardless of the multicultural setting of the country, with a project that materializes nationalist myth in a hegemonic way.14 Benedict Anderson explained that nation-building constructs usually centre around narratives about the past: “(…) the preservation of symbolic loading of the material past as heritage has been pivotal in creating the ‘imagined communities’ of nation-states in the modern era.”15 Obviously, the Greeks consider such claims absurd and argue that the territory now occupied by North Macedonia was not even part of the ancient kingdom of Macedonia (the Romans added it to their province of that name later on in the 2nd century BC).16 North Macedonia is a country of two million people where just over 60 percent are Macedonian, of Orthodox faith; around 25 percent are Albanian, mainly of Mus- lim faith; and the rest are Serb and Vlach (both communities are Orthodox as well), or Turkish, Bosniak, or Roma (which are mostly Muslim).17 This process of creating a history that leads straight back to North Macedonian antiquity was not a neutral and objective process, but a very biased and instrumen-
a Common Past?
3. Skopje 2014, Skopje, North Macedonia (photo: B. Bakal, 2022) Skopje 2014, Skopje, Sjeverna Makedonija, 2014.
talized field of producing of national narratives. Unfortunately, one of the most im- mediate effects this project has been further division of Macedonian citizens along the ethnic lines, since those who are not members of the titular nation – Albanians, Turks, Roma, Serbs, Vlachs and others – have been left out of this dominant dis- course of ethnonationalism.18 Although the Alexander narrative is related to the North Macedonian claim to autochthony, using the figure of Alexander the Great as a cohesive building con- struct for the emerging nation is quite misleading in interpreting the ancient past, especially when revoking Hellenic cultural roots. During Alexander the Great’s reign, the Greeks came in contact with outside peoples and their Hellenic, classical culture blended with cultures from Asia and Africa fusing into Hellenism. The reconstruc- tion, or rather reinvention of their own ancient past/culture has no similarity or con- tinuity with the culture that flourished under Alexander the Great. Hellenism was syncretic, culturally polycentric, and polycausal, being a result of crossing between Hellenic and Oriental thinking, i.e. a phenomenon of permeation and crossing be- tween the classical Hellenic culture and a local, especially Oriental one. Alexander’s policy of racial fusion even brought increasing friction to his relations with his “be- loved” Macedonians. He managed to create a kingdom as a uniform economic and cultural world stretching from the Straits of Gibraltar to the Indus River, with a com- mon civilization that led to the moving of the great centres of civilization eastward.19 The Alexander statue also announced a massive government-sponsored urban renovation plan named Skopje 2014 (Fig. 2) that promised Skopje a new image, one that would deliver to Macedonia a properly “European” capital, an investment in Macedonia’s international recognisability and competitiveness in a global market- place where monuments serve as engines of economic value and “soft power” on the world stage.20 By linking the mythic past to future ambitions, Skopje 2014 supplied a revamped historical narrative to the locals while also packaging a place-based iden- tity for consumption by the foreign tourists (Fig. 3).21
a Common Past?
Although this claim for European belonging came in the age of European in- tegration, such an attempt at reclaiming an ancient past that would situate Skopje and Macedonia within the perceived mainstream of European history was based on “widespread belief that the ancient Greeks were the original fount of modern (i.e. Western) civilization,” which John Hobson identified as the “Greek clause” in Euro- pean historiography.22 Neil Silberman has described this situation in the following way: “The modern discovery of the ancient splendors of the Near East by trained European and American scholars seemed to put Europe and America – rather than modern Egyptians, Palestinians, Turks or Iraqis – in the position of legitimate heirs.”23 Interestingly, there are some similarities in the politics of nation building between these two neighbours, as the Greeks provide an unusually effective demonstration of hegemony since as Europeans they have been taught to adopt a neoclassical posture that accorded with the liberal philhellenism of the tutelary Great Powers.24 As Win- ter has noted in his latest book, “(…) by the nineteenth century Greek antiquity had also been reconstructed as a shared European past, thereby identified as a founda- tion of Western civilization.”25 Herzfeld has also explained that “based on nostalgised Eurocentric construction of their identity, today the modern Greek identity relies on its antiquity, classical past that excludes Islamic, Coptic, Roman, Slavic layers of the past, i.e. non-Hellenic ethnicities that inhabit Greece today.”26 Greek national iden- tity is based on exclusive Hellenic origins, thus Turkish, Macedonian, or Albanian ethnic and cultural influence is erased from the equation.27 While disputing over the country’s name, origin, and heritage, both countries evidence that micro-regional ethnic homogeneity is the goal, and what is determina- tive of ethnicity is history (in this case ancient history), thus it follows that history, or rather specific parts of the past as they exist in the present must be eradicated.28 The Balkan region is a part of the world where “history” is ever so often invoked as the basis for establishing a cultural presence and then discerned, or re-thought, as a form of heritage, especially in Greece, where history is often instantiated in the materiality of archaeological finds of “marble column-filled” classical sites.29 With its obvious political attachment to the images of Greek antiquity, the extensive ex- cavations and presentation of classical cities are clearly linked to modern national self-consciousness.30 Consequently, the Acropolis in Athens acts as “a reservoir of meanings” to the Greeks, to which multiple values, myths, and ideologies can be ascribed in the making of a modern Greek identity.31 In this region, profuse historical ruptures have sedimented in a richly layered history including fragments of earlier periods that stand witness to the frequent changes and mixing of cultures and civilizations, which makes a uniform essentialist narrative in these two countries difficult to achieve. Throughout the Balkan region, management of cultural heritage is a politically charged process, which is also evi- dent from the recently built New Acropolis Museum (2009) in Athens, which epito- mizes the prevailing national ideology. Resurrected from the ashes of a tremendously destabilizing crisis, the Old Acrop- olis Museum in Athens (constructed in 1874 and expanded in 1950s with modern curatorial setting and interpretation) enshrined the aspirations of the dominant cul- tural and political forces in Greece about its role in post-WWII Western world that was rooted in the aesthetic, moral, and ideological legacy of Greece’s classical past.32 In such political climate, architecture was tasked with providing a visual mani- festation of the country’s identity. There was a renewed interest in Greece’s classical heritage, and monuments such as the Parthenon in Athens played an important po- litical role, instilling a nationalistic sense of pride in a populace fatigued by years of civil war and political uncertainty.33 For example, the narratives of Athenian glory, embodied in architectural ruins and artworks, provided what Yannis Hamilakis has referred to as a “monumental topography of the nation.”34
a Common Past?
4. In 1982, the Minister of Culture, Melina Mercouri, started a campaign against the The New Acropolis Museum, British Museum for the reunification of the Parthenon Marbles. The counterargu- Athens, Greece, 2009 (Wikimedia Commons, Jean_Pierre Dalibera, ment of the British Museum was the lack of a suitable place in Athens that could 2016) host and protect the marbles from air pollution.35 The need for a museum became Novi Muzej Akropole, Atena, Grčka, more urgent and an issue of national importance. 2009. Creation of a gallery for displaying the Parthenon Marbles was key to all pro- posals for the design of a new museum and Greek officials expressed their hope that the new museum would help in the campaign for bringing back the Parthenon Marbles. A controversy erupted over the plans for the new museum and whether it was appropriate to build it on the archaeological site in the Makrygianni neighbour- hood (also known as Acropolis), while another concern was whether a large modern building would fit well into the landscape.36 The building of the new museum materializes a political concept that addresses the reunification of the Elgin Marbles. The New Acropolis Museum (NAM) located at the south-eastern slope of the Acropolis Hill in Athens, Greece, was founded in 2003 and opened to the public in June 2009 (Fig. 4).37 It was designed by Bernard Tschumi and his Greek associate Michael Fotiadis. The museum was built to house artefacts found on the hill and the surrounding slopes, from the Greek Bronze Age to Roman and Byzantine Greece. It was set 300 metres away from the Parthenon, which makes it the largest modern building erected so close to an ancient site. 38 But, architecture and politics conflict here in their joint attempt to reconstruct the past. The architecture of the NAM materializes a political statement and ad- dresses the reunification of the Parthenon Marbles, and although it is represented as an autonomous structure inserted in the Athenian landscape, it is not a coherent extension of the Acropolis site, as it protrudes over the urban horizon.39 Such intervention raises a question about the way in which a spatial past is per- ceived in the present and how this is expressed in architectural terms. Winter ex- plains that “the processes of heritage are about ordering the past into particular spa- tialized narratives where the state continues to be a key force exerting its will on the cultural past.”40
a Common Past?
5. The NAM is merely acting as a political statement, an attempt for national unity, Archaeological Museum Skopje, and it appears that the repatriation of the Marbles has always been, and still is, a North Macedonia, 2014 (photo: B. Bakal, 2022) symbol of national identity.41 In 2014, UNESCO offered to mediate between Greece and the United Kingdom to resolve the dispute, but this was later turned down by Novi Arheološki muzej, Skopje, Sjeverna Makedonija, 2014. the British Museum on the basis that UNESCO works with government bodies, not trustees of museums. In 2021, UNESCO issued its first decision on the Parthenon Marbles, calling for the United Kingdom to return them to Greece, but the two- century controversy about the fate of the ancient friezes still prevails.42 Nation branding consists of strategic efforts to formulate national identity as a brand- ed commodity that can motivate and enhance the movement of capital into a country.43 The projects in Skopje and Athens demonstrate how the dominant discourses, whilst seemingly oppositional, are in fact power-ridden, hegemonic discourses, im- posed by the ruling political elite. They are largely organized around three key prop- ositions articulated by the government: that “the project contributes to the growth of the local economy, to the development of tourism and to the reification of subju- gated history.”44 Politics and ideology are integral parts of these two nation-building projects, stipulated by the heritage industry that underlines search for uniqueness in order to generate a pervasive sense of homogeneity. Salzaar has argued that “in globally circulating tourism imaginaries, ideas of cultures as passive, bounded, and homogeneous entities prevail because it is widely assumed by marketers and service providers alike.” 45 Even though some critics claim that the New Acropolis Museum has managed to create a symbol of modern Greece, Dragonas disagrees by arguing: “(…) the NAM consists a powerful tool of identity formulation, which does not renew the special Athenian identity but disintegrates it. It does not review the relationship of the mod- ern city with the antiquity but adjusts the antiquity to the needs of the modern tour- istic industry and it expresses the ideological confusion of our age and especially of modern Greece.”46
a Common Past?
Unlike the New Acropolis Museum, designed in an cutting-edge contemporary architectural expression by a world-renowned architect, the new Archaeological Mu- seum in Skopje (completed in 2014 within the Skopje 2014 project) again simulates “ancient Macedonian” history through its architectural expression, while simultane- ously claiming that the Archaeological Museum of the Republic of North Macedonia finally got its “modern” museum venue (Fig. 5). However, there is no doubt that, although it is “new and modern,” the new Archaeological Museum in Skopje does not say anything about modern North Macedonia. In surveying the role of the past in the present on the example of recent North Macedonian and Greek heritage projects, we may argue that heritage in the Balkans has been of active assistance in the invention of traditions, a process which is, as Hobsbawn explains, “to cloak the present with the respectability of antiquity.”47 What is invented are the condensation symbols that are fused “into one symbolic event, sign, or act patriotic pride, anxieties, remembrances of past glories or humiliations.”48 We can see that, compared to the recent past, the ancient past is more attrac- tive, more loveable, and safer.49 The Mediterranean region has a particular relation- ship to the phenomenon of parochial universalism, as Herzfeld argues, “because it is seen as being at once the fons et origo of Western culture and power, and yet also, in part precisely because of an antiquity that confers both gilded respect and political marginality, as a region was excluded from the advantages of a privileged modernity.”50
SHARING THE COMMON PAST In his latest book on the Silk Road, Winter notes that “by the late nineteenth century much of the research conducted in the ‚Near east’ sought evidence of the regional connections of antiquity and the broader trends of early twentieth century historiography on the Levant, primarily framed the past through Hellenistic and Ro- man connections and the accounts of Alexander the Great, Herodotus, and Ptolemy, as well as writings of more recent European travellers to the region.”51 Such construction of the past reflects a conflict between romantic Orientalism on the one hand and the Eurocentric fear of cultural absorption into something “Middle Eastern” on the other. Orientalism or Eurocentrism is a worldview that asserts the inherent superiority of the West over the East. Specifically, Orientalism constructs a permanent image of the superior West (the “Self ”) that is defined negatively against the no less imaginary “Other” – the backward and inferior East.52 Hobson/s book also argues that the East (which was more advanced than the West between 500 and 1800) provided a crucial role in enabling the rise of modern Western civilization.53 Over the past decade, Greece started to play an important role in narratives about antiquity constructed around the new Silk Road, using it as a connectivity link between East and West, while conjoining different cultures along this route into a transregional heritage concept with common, shared past.54 The research conducted by the Aristotle University in Thessaloniki claims that according to the historical sources and the cultural heritage analysis of Greece, there is a strong common history linking Greece and the Silk Route over the centuries.55 Furthermore, Marx notes that “various civilizations and cultures were connected along the Silk Route length of more than 12.000 km, which makes it arguably the longest cultural route in the history of humanity.”56 Since ancient times, the Silk Road had served as a bridge between East and West, uniting three continents and different cultures along its route (Fig. 6).57 Based on some sources, the UNESCO report claims: “(…) much of the Silk Road and the surrounding regions opened for the first time to the western world by Alexander the Great.”58
a Common Past?
6. Silk Route Map (Wikimedia Commons, NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center, 2010) Mapa Puta svile
These attributions and claims conjoin with the World Tourism Organisation Re- port on Silk Road, which elaborates further: “Alexander the Great (356-323 BC) was one of the first Silk Road travelers from the West. While being on the road with his army for around 10 years, he traveled across Central Asia, Persia Empire and North India. Through his military conquests he opened maritime routes and enabled trad- ing between the East and the West.”59 However, as Tim Winter reminds us, many narrative inventions about the Silk Road’s past are constructed nowadays that lead to misconception and romanticism that puts into question the actual validity of the concept: “There are competing claims over when the Silk Road supposedly opened, to which regions it reached and at what point trade and exchange reached its height. Scholars working across countries and disciplines toil, debate and congregate over Silk Road pasts, adding new themes, locations and forms of connections. All too often it is the present that influences how the past is interpreted.”60 We will see in this chapter that some narratives of the past are forging the ancient Silk Road’s identity in Greece through branding in order to enhance national tour- ism development that they have labelled as a “civilization dialogue.” Nowadays, the Silk Road is revived as an up-and-coming tourist destination engaging numerous countries, with rich natural and cultural heritage. The new Silk Road is a rich tapes- try of tourist destinations and products based on the unique and outstandingly rich heritage, nature, and traditions of dozens of distinct histories, peoples, and cultures. The Silk Road identity of Greece is emphasized in the UNESCO Silk Road Pro- gramme that depicts Greece as located on the edge of the eastern world, playing a major role in the commerce of valuable textiles and other merchandises through the maritime silk routes, and a Silk Road’s production centre in Byzantine times. The traditional silk industry persisted in some Greek cities up to the 19th century with the invention of artificial silk.61 In 1993, the UNWTO (United Nations World Tourism Organization) launched the Silk Road Programme, a collaborative initiative designed to enhance sustainable tourism development along the historic Silk Road, aiming to maximize the benefits of tourism development for the local Silk Road communities, while stimulating in- vestment and promoting the conservation of the route’s natural and cultural heritage.
a Common Past?
7. A key segment of this programme is the Western Silk Road (WSR) Tourism De- Map of the main nodes along velopment Initiative, a joint tourism project launched by UNWTO and the European the Silk Route and the branded heritage sites in Greece (Silk Road Union (EU) in 2016. The project aims at revitalizing the Silk Road heritage located Programme 2016, Western Silk Road in the European region: around the Caspian Sea and the Black Sea, and along parts Tourism Initiative, a UNWTO-EU of the Mediterranean basin.62 The main assets that have motivated UNWTO and the Initiative, 2016, p. 19) EU to pursue this joint project are the untapped unique Silk Road heritage of the Mapa glavnih čvorišta i „brendiranih“ region, the available land and sea routes, the diverse cultural assets and the market baštinskih lokaliteta Puta svile u that increasingly demands authentic travel experience, features that the travellers Grčkoj can also easily come across in Greece. Once applied to the entire Silk Road region, the label will reinforce the idea of the Silk Road as a cultural and trading route consisting of many different countries and also identify the participating Silk Road tourist destinations as such.63 This branding of the Silk Road identity across the country connects and links tangible and intangible cultural heritage in Greek key destinations, revealing the “hidden” resources directly or indirectly related to the Silk Road in order to dif- ferentiate end enrich tourism products and provide sustainable development for the less developed regions (Fig. 7).64
a Common Past?
8. Silk Museum, Soufli, Greece, 1990 (Wikimedia Commons, Kalogeropoulus, 2014) Muzej svile, Soufli, Grčka, 1990.
For example, the small Greek town of Soufli in eastern Macedonia is hoping to revive its long-dead local economy, silk production, as a way to bring tourists to northeastern Greece.65 The Art Silk Museum of Soufli is a living thematical museum of sericulture whose main aim is to promote the local cultural identity of Soufli as an important Silk Road destination in order to attract local and foreign visitors (Fig. 8). As stated in the Western Silk Road report by the Aristotle University: “Thessa- loniki, the second largest city of Greece, located in Macedonia, was a crossroads of the Great Silk Road for many centuries. Thessaloniki was the most important port of the eastern Roman Empire and – along with the Via Egnatia route, the city func- tioned an important role, in relation to the Silk Road. Among the industrial heritage complexes of Thessaloniki, there is the silk mill ‘Helios’, dating from 1931 to 1947, and the complex was classified in 1991 as a ‘protected historical monument’.”66 Obviously, when it comes to new museums of the Silk Road in Greece, “economic considerations opened the way to an era in which archeological resources of antiquity were selectively exploited, not for scientific or ideological reasons but according to someone’s idea of what sells.”67 Heritage, the most visual of the historical disciplines, is inescapably didactic. The full complexity of its political and ideological associations, whether nationalist or postcolonial, sometimes merely paves the way for the disci- pline’s exploitation by other, even more transcendent ideologies – profit and tourism. The focus of UNWTO, the EU and the WSR Initiative is primarily on the use of Silk Road heritage to construct the image of a tourist destination and to provide a foundation for the Western Silk Road to function as a fully operative tourism brand. Therefore, we see the antiquity again being promoted, not for nation branding, but as a multicultural tourism brand, since the narratives about it are here centred on the notions of shared past between different cultures and cultural internationalism. Along the new Silk Road, a celebration of shared civilizational heritage is being constructed around imaginings of a glorious antiquity of East and West conjoined by this new route. Civilizational imaginaries are used to forge connections between East and West, and specifically between China and the Mediterranean, while focus- ing on Greece, thus emphasizing their “shared” heritage via archaeology and new heritage sites and museums related to the Silk Road. Silk Road discourses craft pasts and futures around certain ideologies analysed through specific concepts/images/effects, i.e. a system of imaginary representations
a Common Past?
such as the “shared destiny” or “shared past” that are reading the regions differently in a form that is interpreted as a dialogue. The new Silk Road dialogue is producing knowledge of a “shared multicultural history” for the purpose of international trade using maritime Silk Route ports to exchange commodities, capital, and technology, as well as for the purpose of exploiting heritage tourism.68 Winter explains that the new Silk Road has also become a platform on which particular transnational corridors of heritage production are now forming; thus, culture and heritage are now being used to maintain or build relations with others where histories and cultural pasts overlap.69 However, just like the narratives of empires or nations, Silk Road histories are constructs that also carry political consequences. Winter argues that the introduc- tion of Sinocentric narratives of connectivity and civilization is perhaps especially charged for regions where borders and cultural sovereignties are contested or where artefacts, cultural practices, and archaeological sites are already enmeshed in the memory politics of nationalism. He explains it in the following words: “In a world of Silk Road cooperation, that which is celebrated as ‘shared’ is inevitably a small, carefully selected, carefully curated part of conjoined pasts. (…) It often finds fertile ground where there is, in reality, little shared history.”70 Speaking about the conjoined pasts and metaphysical ties between Greece and China, Professor Zhang Lihua (director of the Research Centre for China-EU Rela- tions at Tsinghua University) emphasized during her visit to Greece in 2014: “The philosophers of Greece, like the philosophers of China shaped the ideational cul- tures of two of the world’s greatest empires located opposite of the Eurasian land- mass: The Greco-Roman Culture and the Han-Tang culture. (…) Greece like China are civilizations pretending to be nation states with millennia old histories and very diverse traditions.”71 Thus, it is not too surprising that during the opening event of “Greece-China Year of Culture & Tourism 2021” (when culture and tourism relations are celebrated together for the first time), statues of the ancient Greek philosopher Socrates and the Chinese philosopher Confucius were unveiled at the archaeological site of Ancient Agora near the Acropolis hill in the centre of Athens. The sculpture titled “Socrates and Confucius: A Meeting” was made by the curator of the National Art Museum of China (NAMOC), Wu Weishan, who donated the artwork.72 This heritage construct of rewriting history reduces complex, fragmented events into a single overarching romanticized narrative and raises the question whether Eu- rocentric histories of premodern past are now going to be overlaid with Sinocentric depictions.73 Sino-Hellenic cooperation is developing in many relevant areas, such as the pre- vention of theft and illegal trade of cultural relics; the Ancient Civilization Forum; protection of cultural and natural heritage; or opening of the Chinese cultural cen- tre in Athens dedicated to heritage preservation & underwater archaeology (2016) in order to better understand their shared values. Furthermore, the new Silk Road provides a golden opportunity for the Mediterranean countries – especially Greece – that seek to liberate themselves from Western hegemony and Eurocentrism, and decolonize the image of the Mediterranean as premodern. Still, identifying the cultural heritage of the Silk Road, as Winter notes, requires Greece and other Mediterranean countries “to look beyond its own borders, flatten out the sense of hierarchy between different ethnic groups and in part to relinquish the concept of patrimoine national in favor of a language of shared heritage and diversity.”74 Therefore, using the Silk Road as a heritage vehicle might provoke and enable Greece to adopt a policy of cultural internationalism in the attempt to coun- ter the hegemony of ancient pasts associated with the territorial nation.75
a Common Past?
CONCLUSION Images and symbols from the past play conspicuous and powerful roles in the present. We have seen how remnants from the past become battle-banners of mod- ern ethnic groups and nations; and how heritage interpretation can often reflect and reinforce the centralizing policies of emerging nation-states. This article attempts to show that nationalist/hegemonic bias in heritage interpretation evidences that herit- age has by its nature an unavoidable political dimension – and that, as Silberman states, “nationalism or hegemony is simply one of many possible manifestations of its character as both a scientific and a political enterprise.”76 Focus on distinctive national histories is to some extent a result of the Eurocen- tric bias that continues to pervade international organizations dedicated to heritage conservation.77 While contemporary heritage discourses have privileged the era of European dis- coveries, colonialism, and intraregional maritime trade, Winter argues that the con- cept of Silk Road, regardless of its thematic and empirical biases, “will go some way to making the cultural paraphernalia of national identity less inwardly territorial, the identities of the region’s cities less culturally centripetal, and perhaps, the narratives of the world history a little less Eurocentric.”78 Critical analyses of recent north Macedonian and Greek heritage have revealed that objects are a “potent force in forging self-consciousness,“ and play important roles in the construction and expression of national, ethnic identities. Paradoxically, the crux of contestation between North Macedonia and Greece is their “shared past” embedded in the figure of Alexander the Great, but unlike the Silk Road’s “shared past,” which connects different cultures and nations, the former is a cause of mutual conflict, enmity, and potential violence between the two coun- tries involved. The fact is that the entire Balkans has been a mixture of cultures and civilisations throughout its long and rich layered history. Quoting Michael Her- zfeld: “And even if historians of Europe may neglect the Balkans, they do not neglect Greece, if only because in the established schema of European history it holds an inalienable place as the fountainhead of European culture.”79 The hegemony of heritage lies in the will and means to control heritage sites on the ground. The power to imagine these sites as linked to specific historical periods, while ignoring others, gives a variety of people the agency to curate their material in the present through praxis and for the future – either intentionally or not – via the tangible residue.80 The heritage of the Balkans (and the Mediterranean) conveys a pervasive sense of hegemony in which power relations are continually reasserted, challenged, and modified. Furthermore, as Herzfeld argues, “the Mediterranean re- gion exhibits a particularly tight association between cultures deemed to be ancient with relatively young nation-states embroiled in crises that bespeak the discontents of aggressive modernity: war and nationalist extremism.”81 Compared to this sense of pervasive homogeneity (hegemonic appreciation of the ancient past) that marks this region, the new Silk Road’s internationalism based on antiquity i.e. a “shared past” that is constructed and reconstructed around the ideals of cosmopolitanism, tolerance, and intercultural dialogue, “privileges ideas of transoceanic and transcontinental exchange between East and West, harmony and open borders that could be viewed as a response to the destructive consequences of modern nationalism.”82 Critical approaches to heritage are today increasingly moving toward the devel- opment of cross-culturally oriented approaches to the management, care, and inter- pretation of their sites, with the intention of liberating them from the hegemony of Eurocentrism.83 Thus, the Mediterranean region (along with the Balkans) unravels
a Common Past?
as a site for rethinking comparatively about the significance of different geopolitical, national, regional, linguistic, and cultural contexts that might provoke new, counter- hegemonic heritage dialogues in the future.
NOTES 1 MICHAEL HERZFELD, Practical Mediterraneism: Excuses for 15 BENEDICT ANDERSON, Imagined Communities: Reflections on Everything, from Epistemology to Eating, in: Rethinking the Med- the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, Verso, New York, 2016, 87. iterranean, (ed. William V. Harris), Oxford University Press, New 16 GORAN JANEV, Skopje 2014: Instrumentalizing Heritage for York, 2006, 45-64. Unexpected Results (April 12, 2015), available at: https://www. 2 MICHAEL HERZFELD, Po Mo-Med, in: A Companion to Medi- cultures-of-history.uni-jena.de/debates/skopje-2014-instrumen- terranean History, (ed. Peregrine Horden and Sharon Kinoshita), talizing-heritage-for-unexpected-results. 2014, Wiley-Blackwell, Hoboken, NJ, 122-135. 17 ANDREW GRAAN, ALEKSANDAR TAKOVSKI, Learning 3 MANUEL BORUTTA, A Colonial Sea: The Mediterranean 1798- from Skopje 2014: Architectural Spectacle in the 21st Century, 1956, European Review of History, 19/1 (February 2012), 1-13. LA+ Interdisciplinary Journal of Landscape Architecture (April 2017), 69-73. 4 Ibid., 1-13. 18 Ibidem. 5 PHILLIP L. KOHL, CLARE FAWCETT, Archeology in the Ser- vice of the State: Theoretical Considerations, in: Nationalism, 19 IRMA MARX, Empire of Alexander the Great – Expansion into Politics and Practice of Archeology, (ed. Philip L. Kohl, Clare Faw- Asia and Central Asia, available at: http://www.silkroadfounda- cett), Cambridge University Press, New York, 1995, 3-21. tion.org/artl/alex.shtml. 6 TIMOTHY KAISER, Archeology and Ideology in Southeast Eu- 20 ANDREW GRAAN, Counterfeiting the Nation? Skopje 2014 rope, in: Nationalism, Politics and Practice of Archeology (note 5), and the Politics of Nation Branding in Macedonia, Cultural AN- 99-120. THROPOLOGY 28/1, 161-179. 7 Ibid., 113. 21 ANDREW GRAAN, ALEKSANDAR TAKOVSKI (note 17), 69-73. 22 TIM WINTER, Geocultural Power: China’s Quest to Revive the 8 Ibidem. Silk Roads for the Twenty-First Century, Chicago University Press, 9 PHILLIP L. KOHL, CLARE FAWCETT (note 5), 12. Chicago, 2020, 60-63. 10 AMY HOLGUIN, Alexander the Great in Skopje: An “Up Yours” 23 Ibidem. to Greece?, Uncomfortable Oxford (November 23, 2020), available 24 MICHAEL HERZFELD (note 2), 122-135. at: https://www.uncomfortableoxford.co.uk/post/alexander-the- great-in-skopje-an-up-yours-to-greece. 25 TIM WINTER, The Silk Road: Connecting Histories and Futures, Oxford University Press, New York, 2022, 23-34. 11 AMY HOLGUIN (note 10). 26 MICHAEL HERZFELD, Anthropology: Theoretical Practice in Cul- 12 Ibidem. ture and Society, Wiley-Blackwell, Hoboken, NJ, 2001, 674-675. 13 The Tricky Politics of Tearing down Statues of Alexander the 27 MICHAEL HERZFELD (note 26), 674. Great, The Economist (March 19, 2020), available at: https://www. economist.com/europe/2020/03/19/the-tricky-politics-of-tear- 28 TIMOTHY KAISER (note 6), 116. ing-down-statues-of-alexander-the-great. 29 MICHAEL HERZFELD (note 26), 674. 14 ALEKSANDAR TAKOVSKI, MAJA MUHIĆ, Redefining Na- 30 NEIL ASHER SILBERMAN, Promised Lands and Chosen Peo- tional Identity in Macedonia: Analyzing Competing Origin ples: The Politics and Poetics of Archeological Narrative, in: Na- Myths and Interpretations through Hegemonic Representations, tionalism, Politics and Practice of Archeology (note 5), 249-262. Etnološka tribina 37/44 (2014), 138-152. 31 TIM WINTER (note 25), 23.
a Common Past?
32 NASSOS PAPALEXANDROU, The Old Acropolis Museum, Ath- over 6,400 kilometers (4,000 miles), it played a central role in fa- ens, Greece: An Overdue Necrology, Journal of Modern Greek cilitating economic, cultural, political, and religious interactions Studies 34/1 (May 2016), 1-22. between East and West. In addition to goods, the network facili- 33 VALIA RASSA, Concept, Content, Context: Situating the New tated an unprecedented exchange of ideas, religions, philosophies, Acropolis Museum into the Athenian Context, The Bartlett School and scientific discoveries, many of which were syncretised or re- of Architecture, University College London, MAAH 2015, 57-65. shaped by the societies that encountered them. JERRY BENTLEY, Old World Encounters: Cross-Cultural Contacts and Exchanges in 34 YANNIS HAMILAKIS, The Nation and Its Ruins: Antiquity, Ar- Pre-Modern Times, Oxford University Press, New York, 1993, 32. cheology and National Imagination in Greece, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2007, 58. 58 UNESCO Silk Road Programme, Greece, available at: https://en. unesco.org/silkroad/countries-alongside-silk-road-routes/greece. 35 VALIA RASSA (note 33), 57-65. 59 UNWTO World Tourism Organization, Silk Road Action Plan 36 Akropolis Museum, Wikipedia, available at: https://en.wikipedia. 2016/2017, UNWTO, 2016, 4-24. org/wiki/Acropolis_Museum. 37 Ibidem. 60 TIM WINTER (note 25), 3-17. 38 VALIA RASSA (note 33), 57-65. 61 UNESCO Silk Road Programme, Greece (note 58). 39 Ibidem. 62 UNWTO World Tourism Organization, Silk Road Action Plan 2016/2017 (note 59). 40 TIM WINTER (note 22), 5-36. 63 Ibidem. 41 VALIA RASSA (note 33), 57-65. 64 STELLA KOSTOPULOU (note 55), 13. 42 ELIZABETH DJINIS, Can Greece and the U.K. Finally Broker a Deal to Return the Elgin Marbles to Athens? Smithsonian Maga- 65 Ibid., 19. zine (May 20, 2022), a vailable at: https://www.smithsonianmag. 66 Ibid., 22. com/smart-news/can-greece-and-uk-finally-broker-deal-to-re- 67 NEIL SILBERMAN (note 30), 249-262. turn-elgin-marbles-parthenon-sculptures-athens-180980113/. 68 TIM WINTER (note 22), 5-36. 43 ANDREW GRAAN (note 20), 161-179. 69 Ibid., 110. 44 Ibidem. 70 TIM WINTER (note 25), 173-181. 45 NOEL B. SALAZAR, The Power of Imagination in Transnation- al Mobilities, Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power 18 71 VASILIS TRIGKAS, The New Silk Road: Cultural & Economic (2011), 576-598. Diplomacy China-Greece Europe, 2020, available at: http://www. dir.tsinghua.edu.cn/iren/info/1030/1064.htm. 46 PANOS DRAGONAS, After (the) Acropolis, Architecture in Greece 44 (2010), 128-130. 72 Greece-China Year of Culture and Tourism 2021 Begins in May, Greek City Times (January 28, 2021), available at: https://greekci- 47 ERIC HOBSBAWM, The Invention of Tradition, Cambridge Uni- tytimes.com/2021/01/28/greece-china-culture-tourism-may. versity Press, Cambridge, UK, 1983, 83. 73 TIM WINTER (note 22), 1-17. 48 TIMOTHY KAISER (note 6), 119. 74 TIM WINTER (note 25), 173-181. 49 NEIL SILBERMAN (note 30), 249-262. 75 Ibidem. 50 MICHAEL HERZFELD (note 2), 122-135. 76 NEIL SILBERMAN (note 30), 249-262. 51 TIM WINTER (note 25), 25. 77 MICHAEL HERZFELD (note 2), 122. 52 JOHN HOBSON, Eastern Origins of Western Civilization, Cam- bridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2004, 2. 78 TIM WINTER (note 22), 170. 53 Ibid., 3. 79 PEREGRINE HORDEN, NICHOLAS PURCELL, The Corrupting Sea: A Study of Mediterranean History, Wiley-Blackwell, Hobo- 54 The New Silk Road or BRI (Belt One Road Initiative) is a global ken, NJ, 2006, 176. infrastructure development strategy adopted by the Chinese gov- ernment in 2013, to invest in countries and international organi- 80 DEBORAH L.STEIN, The Hegemony of Heritage, Ritual and the zations worldwide. It is a trade network that involves Asia, Africa, Record in Stone, University of California Press, Oakland, CA, and Europe and as of March 2022, 146 countries were listed as 2018, 243-250. having signed up to the BRI. Cf. Belt and Road Initiative, available 81 MICHAEL HERZFELD (note 2), 122-140. at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative. 82 TIM WINTER (note 25), 1-17. 55 STELLA KOSTOPULOU, The Western Silk Road in Greece, 83 CHRISTINA F. KREPS, Liberating Culture: Cross-Cultural Per- Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Department of Economics, spectives on Museums, Curation and Heritage, London, Rout- Laboratory of Applied Economincs and Development, Silk Road ledge, 2003, 149. Programme 2016, Western Silk Road Tourism Initiative, a UN- WTO-EU Initiative, 2016, 6. 56 IRMA MARX (note 19). 57 The Silk Road was a network of Eurasian trade routes active from the second century BCE until the mid-15th century. Spanning