Introduction
In an era defined by neoliberal and cognitive capitalism, contemporary art has increasingly turned towards pragmatic and didactic approaches, advocating axio- matically affirmative perspectives. Amid the destructive impact of human-centred technological progress, the ambiguities of economic configurations reflecting the logic of capitalism, and the exploitation of nature and science for financial gain, the sequence of events becomes such that the world must think about matters of ethics across various domains of existence. In such circumstances, contemporary hybrid art presents a unique opportunity to challenge oppressive mental frameworks, as its value lies in its capacity to affect, influence, and initiate tangible change within societal configurations. This paper posits that contemporary hybrid art practices are striving to redefine their objective towards environmental activism, promoting a more balanced and egalitarian existence among species. The following section outlines the terminology used in this paper, some of which is explained in the endnotes. To begin with, the term hybrid art refers to transdisci- plinary and experimental artistic practices that emerge at the intersection of science and art. Ecological art denotes artistic production that concerns artists’ attitudes towards any environmental situation. Serbian art theorist Miško Šuvaković defines ecological art as “based on direct and active engagement with the environment and the relations between nature and the artificial world of culture.”1 The term tech- nology here refers to the practical application of scientific discoveries and knowl- edge. Western art and philosophy have long engaged with the concept of politics. Croatian philosopher Vladimir Filipović points out that “politics as practice is more or less directly related to political theory and philosophy,”2 further noting that “in contrast to ancient philosophical traditions, modern theories, almost without excep- tion, conceive of politics as force and power.”3 In her book On the Political, Belgian political theorist Chantal Mouffe explains: “[...] by ‘the political’ I mean the dimension of antagonism which I take to be constitutive of human societies, while by ‘politics’ I mean the set of practices and institutions through which an order is created, organizing human coexistence in the context of conflictuality provided by the political.”4 In this paper, I use the term political to denote the aspiration for ethical multi- species coexistence, grounded in the imperative that all beings – human and non- human – should be treated with dignity and respect. My perspective of the term political practice implies artistic strategies and interventions that critically engage with power relations, challenging and destabilizing dominant hierarchical structures among species. The case study chosen for this essay is the art project Confronting Vegetal Oth- erness: Phytoteratology by Slovenian new media artist Špela Petrič. The title of the artwork draws on Félix Guattari’s concept of ecosophy and Donna Haraway’s argu- ments on interspecies relations, both of which contribute to the theoretical frame- work of this essay. Two hypotheses arise from the thesis statement. The first explores Guattari’s con- cept of ecosophy, with the objective to demonstrate that ecosophy can be embodied in contemporary hybrid art strategies. The reasons for selecting Guattari’s theoreti- cal apparatus are that contemporary art is a suitable place for ecological revolution, capable of reconfiguring the relationships between human beings and what is tradi- tionally considered external and natural world, and that art is a powerful instrument in criticizing dominant paradigms.
Ecological Integration
The second hypothesis draws on Donna Haraway’s theoretical position from her book When Species Meet, which emphasizes the necessity to rethink the position of non-human being beyond the limit of considering the human being as an on- tological basis, thus subverting the power relations among species. The parameters for choosing Haraway’s book are multilayered and support this discussion based on several conceptual and thematic analogies, including her critique of anthropocen- trism and her reconceptualization of the traditional notions of species boundaries and ethics. This research is conceived as a transdisciplinary overview and analysis of rel- evant theoretical positions. The aim is to offer a possible model for conceptualizing art as a political and social practice that extends its scope to the non-human world. Another objective is to examine whether the application of Haraway’s and Guattari’s theoretical positions can enrich reflections on art’s role in the post-Anthropocene era. Additional methodologies include observation and description of what art does and can possibly do as a social practice integrating non-human life. The synthe- sis will attempt to align Petrič’s artwork with the arguments proposed by Guattari and Haraway. With respect to these theoretical models and the case study, the essay demonstrates the modalities of existence and mental articulation, along with their practical influence on the world, that a work of art can embody. The first part of the essay is devoted to Špela Petrič’s artwork titled Confronting Vegetal Otherness: Phytoteratology. The following sections explore Guattari’s concept of ecosophy and its relevance to illustrating the position of ecological art, as well as Donna Haraway’s discussion of multispecies sociality, which is here considered as an adequate theoretical apparatus5 for analysing Petrič’s project as a case study. The final section examines how contemporary hybrid art practices can address the issue of environmental injustice.
Confronting Vegetal Otherness: Phytoteratology by Špela Petrič In her work Confronting Vegetal Otherness: Phytoteratology, Slovenian artist Špela Petrič proposes alternative modes of procreation. Petrič explains: “I pro-create plant-human entities, which I lovingly call monsters, via in vitro conception and hormonal alteration. The project embodies my desire to conceive and mother a trans-plant, to conjoin the gentle green alien, metaphysically dubbed the most primal of life forms, the barest of bare life, and my animalistic, politicised humanness harbor- ing a culturally pregnant mind.”6 Plant embryos are cultivated in artificial “wombs,” in preference to traditional seed cultivation. The artist applies hormonal nourishment with hormones derived from her own urine, creating an artificial growth environment in the process of plant embryos procreation that allows her to critically rethink the mechanisms of plant subordination. Petrič’s artwork is excessive in that it compels the audience to move from indif- ference to critical reflection on the power dynamics between the human and non- human worlds, and this political and ethical excess is its distinctive feature. The art- ist challenges traditional ethical boundaries across multiple layers, such as humans daring to create life and intervene in the natural world, and art’s role in fostering a more egalitarian and moral stance towards plants. Petrič also contests the roles of science, art, and technology, challenging dominant scientific paradigms. The ethical questions Petrič raises concern humanity’s ambition to intervene in the non-human domain and to modify nature along with its creation processes. She
Ecological Integration
suggests that human experimentation on plants need not always serve human well- being, and that plants need not be bred exclusively for human consumption or any other pragmatic purpose. As the artist explains: “These tiny monsters, coming into being from an impossible love, with intense labor and a yearning of plant parent- hood, emerge in a time of environmental, political and social crisis as beings of permeability, harbingers of affective agential intra-action.”7 Petrič’s art project thus challenges the presupposed dominance of human beings over plants, advocating for a more intricate and multidimensional apprehension of 1. multispecies correlations. In doing so, she disrupts and subverts societal hierarchies Špela Petrič, plant-human monsters, 30x magnification, within the artworld and beyond, adopting an approach that extracts art practices detail from the work from the artworld. Confronting Vegetal Otherness: Phytoteratology, Het “Parenthood” Glazen Huis, produced by Zone2Source, Amstelpark Another significant aspect of Petrič’s project is her transgression and subversion Amsterdam, 2016. (the photo of parenthood. The artist anthropomorphizes the “baby plants,” referring to them in is courtesy of Špela Petrič) human-like language, and playfully satirizes the anthropocentric tendency to assign Špela Petrič, biljno-ljudska human characteristics to the non-human world. She thus provides an alternative čudovišta, povećanje 30x, detalj view of motherhood by means of transgression and disrupts the established views on djela Suočavanje s vegetalnom drugošću: Fitoteratologija, Het what motherhood entails. As Petrič explains: “Hormones are primordial messenger Glazen Huis, Zone2Source, molecules, stemming from a common evolutionary parent of plants, animals and Amstelpark Amsterdam, 2016. microbes.”8 She continues:
Ecological Integration
“In Phytoteratology, a bit of embryonic tissue is taken from the thale cress (Arabidopsis thaliana), a common weed, and submitted to my care, compassion, and commitment. Biotechnological protocols and science allow me to nurture the tissue into a myriad of plant embryos, conceived not in a seed but an artificial womb, the incubator. I extract steroids from my urine to assist the embryo development, the mol- ecules speaking to them of my presence, in response to which they alter their epigenetic patterns and grow a unique body morphology. These tiny monsters, coming into being from an impossible love, with intense labor and a yearning of plant parenthood, emerge in a time of environmental, political and social crisis as beings of permeability, harbingers of affective agential intra-action. Making kin with plants, caring for us, hopeful monsters.”9
Exaggeration Petrič’s artwork employs intentional exaggeration in several aspects.10 To begin with, she creates plant-human hybrids, thus crossing the boundaries of what is cul- turally, politically, and ethically acceptable. The outcome of her project is a “hybrid family,” also the title of a famous work by the Slovenian artist Maja Smrekar. This “hybrid” family does not share blood relations but is linked through the steroids extracted from Petrič’s urine. Aspects of exaggeration are also present in her strategy of disrupting natural cycles and artificially amplifying the tension between what is discursively constituted as organic and synthetic. Within this context, the position of plants has been transfigured to active participation in a shared biological and political space. In other words, the alternative ecosystem generates its own power dynamics, hierarchical structure, and discursive antagonisms.
The Three Ecologies and the Issues Surrounding Anthropocentrism and post-Anthropocentrism The term “Anthropocene” was coined in the 2000s by the Dutch chemist Paul Crutzen and the American scientist Eugene F. Stoermer to define the current geolog- ical epoch, marked by significant human impact on the composition of Earth’s crust. German philosopher and cultural theorist Peter Sloterdijk considers the human role as “geologically relevant,”11 emphasizing humanity’s profound, indirect influence on Earth’s systems. This impact is particularly evident in the extensive use of fossil fuels and the pervasive production and discharge of non-degradable plastics, which leaves a lasting geological mark. Plastic is ubiquitous and infiltrates so many aspects of our daily lives that its presence is easy to take for granted, yet its ecological footprint is immense.12 In her text “Life and Death in the Anthropocene: A Short History of Plastic,” Canadian theorist and cultural critic Heather Davis explains: “Plastic – in its production, distribution, and waste cycles – represents the inevitable corollary to unfettered economic growth: it is both in- tensely resource-depleting (eight percent of world oil production goes into the manufacture and production of plastics) and ecologically dev- astating. Indeed, plastic brings together some of the most abiding envi- ronmental concerns of our time because of its pervasiveness, banality, and longevity.”13 Plastic pollution in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems, and its discernible effect, call attention to the need for a philosophical transition away from anthropocen- trism, as foregrounded in post-anthropocentric tendencies that question human-
Ecological Integration
centred paradigms. A critical aspect of post-anthropocentrism is the scrutiny of technology, which transforms the relationships between the human and non-hu- man worlds, and their environment, often simultaneously enhancing and disrupt- ing these connections. Post-anthropocentrism is a philosophical and theoretical position that attempts to transcend anthropocentrism, which places human beings at the centre of the world and prioritizes human needs and interests. What ecology does and strives to do aligns with post-anthropocentrism, highlighting an inclu- sive approach and connectedness between organisms. In her book The Ethics of Earth Art, contemporary art theorist Amanda Boetzkes suggests that natural life is not self-sustained and that there can be no untouched nature that exists unrelated to human activity: “[...] natural life is not autoproduced or automaintained; it is always already produced by the technologies that manage it, and always for human purposes. Thus, there is no nature that is not thought through ecotechnology, through a reductive biological model, through conser- vation, resource management, sustainability, or environmental crisis, or in short, through a human-oriented framework. Nature is consti- tuted by technological processes of denaturalization.”14 Therefore, incorporating ecological perspectives into art and other human prac- tices requires exposing the limitations of anthropocentrism position and acknowl- edging these constraints to foster a more fluid, integrated relationship with the ex- ternal world. Reflecting on the use of coal,15 petroleum,16 and power engines,17 alongside the discovery of electricity shortly before 1800 and its technological mastery in the 19th century,18 Peter Sloterdijk posits: “The collective that today is characterized with terms such as ‘humanity,’ and whose influence on Earth is described as ‘anthropo- genic,’ consists mainly of agents who have, in less than one century, appropriated the technologies developed in Europe.”19 Therefore, Sloterdijk continues, “In this case one should rather speak of a ‘Eurocene’ or a ‘Technocene’ initiated by Europeans.”20 Exploring the notions of Eurocentrism and technocentrism aligns with the exami- nation of power relations, partly providing a contextual framework for exploring Guattari’s notion of ecology as it challenges capitalist subjectivity and questions the power structures inherent in capitalism. The reason why I have linked the notion of Eurocentrism and Guattari’s phi- losophy in this text stems from the philosopher’s criticism of global capitalist struc- tures that operate through a Eurocentric logic of progress, development, and mo- dernity. Guattari writes: “There can be little doubt that around the world increased pollution, global warming, deforestation, desertification and the loss of biodiversity are anthropogenic, or that the motor of this generalized impoverishment of the biosphere is capitalism.”21 Guattari describes ecosophy as “an ethico-political articulation.”22 The main point of ecosophy is that the ecological crisis calls for a radical rethinking of our percep- tions and our interaction with the environment, society, and human subjectivity. Ecosophy aspires to study the human condition within the context of its environ- ment, thus indicating that nature and culture are inseparable entities. In his book The Three Ecologies, Guattari challenges traditional views on the eco- logical crisis: “The only true response to the ecological crisis is on a global scale, provided that it brings about an authentic political, social and cultural revolution, reshaping the objectives of the production of both material and immaterial assets.”23 French philosopher Manola Antonioli elaborates in her text “What is Ecosophy”:
Ecological Integration
“In opposition to the standardized discourse about ‘sustainable devel- opment’, which emphasizes (often in a sanctimonious and guilt-induc- ing manner) the relations between ‘individuals’ and their environment, ecosophy (especially in its Guattarian variant, which I specifically re- fer to here) draws our attention to the plurality of ecologies, environ- ments, habitats, that do not ‘surround’ us as a container would envelop its contents, but that define us and that we constantly defi ne and re- configure in a network of relations.”24 It is through ecosophy that solidarity and ecological harmony can be restored. This reconfiguration of the dynamics between living beings, their environments, and the discourses surrounding them, as well as incorporeal species, can be achieved through a renewed sense of responsibility among individuals. Guattari distinguishes three ecological registers: Environmental ecology: According to Guattari, environmental ecology has an imperative to reconstruct the planet and its natural environment, seeking solutions and proactive engagement with the dynamics and mechanisms of evolution. His warnings focus on biodiversity, ecosystems, and interactions between organisms and their environment. There can be little doubt that the increased pollution, global warming, deforestation, desertification, and the loss of biodiversity are anthropo- genic, or that the motor of this generalized impoverishment of the biosphere is capi- talism.25 Guattari explains that natural balance will gradually become dependent on human activity, necessitating programs to regulate atmospheric composition. Even though industries that implement AI promote sustainable solutions, environmental concerns accompany the development of these technologies, notably in electronic waste disposal, pollution, energy consumption, and emissions from data centres. As Amanda Boetzkes notes: “Through the enactment of an ethical responsiveness to space, the artwork brings this earthly component into view, evidencing the way in which natural phenomena are integral to defining the sites of human conflicts, poli- tics, and social formations.”26 Guattari similarly observes: “Environmental ecology, as it exists today, has barely begun to prefigure the generalized ecology that I advo- cate here, the aim of which will be to radically decenter social struggles and ways of coming to one’s own psyche.”27” Boetzkes defines ecology as follows: “In its strictest sense, ecology is the study of the interaction of organ- isms with their environment. It is predicated on the principle that every creature is connected to every element that composes the envi- ronment, so that all living things depend on the balance of a complex system of growth and decay.”28 Boetzkes’s holistic understanding of ecology aligns with Guattari’s expanded per- spective, encouraging a shift away from the entrenched anthropocentric views of progress that understand human beings as isolated entities, while Guattari advo- cates the interrelation of human societies, human subjectivity, and ecosystems. Both perspectives underscore the necessity of recognizing the interdependence of social, political, and mental realms, challenging the isolation of human beings as inherently more valuable than non-human life. Social ecology: Social ecosophy aims to restructure human relations and modes of production, extending its scope to the reconstruction of collective existence and addressing the need for protection from “mass media subjectivity”29 and the pur- suit of social justice within capitalistic frameworks. Guattari explains: “An essential programmatic point for social ecology will be to encourage capitalist societies to make the transition from the mass-media era to a post-media age, in which the
Ecological Integration
media will be reappropriated by a multitude of subject-groups capable of directing its resingularization.”30 He notes: “It is not only species that are becoming extinct but also the words, phrases, and gestures of human solidarity.”31 Guattari calls for alternative value systems and a unified, collective political ap- proach to prevent the marginalization of social ecology: “It seems evident that, unless a politically coherent stance is taken by collective praxes, social ecology will ultimately always be dominated by reactionary nationalist enterprises hostile to any innovation, op- pressing women, children and the marginalized. I am not proposing a ready-made model of society here, but simply the acceptance of a com- plete range of ecosophical components so as to institute, in particular, new systems of valorization.”32 Mental ecology: In the realm of mental ecology, Guattari explores the psycholog- ical dimension in ecological registers, which overlaps with environmental and social ecologies. He critiques Integrated World Capitalism (IWC) for its detrimental im- pact not only on the environment and the social dimension of communities, but also for the fact that its scope extends, in an underhanded manner, to the mental well- being of individuals. Guattari emphasizes the need for a higher degree of solidarity and a sense of collective responsibility to transform human subjectivity and establish alternative value systems. He explains: “It is equally imperative to confront capital- ism’s effects in the domain of mental ecology in everyday life: individual, domestic, material, neighbourly, creative or one’s personal ethics.”33 His critique of capitalist logic advocates for a more integrative and ethically responsible approach, urging his readers to “reevaluate the purpose of work and of human activities according to dif- ferent criteria than those of profit and yield.”34
How Does the Concept of Ecosophy Contribute to Illustrating the Po- sition of Ecological Art? In the following section, my aim is to demonstrate how Guattari’s notion of ecoso- phy illustrates the position and potential of hybrid ecological art. This includes ex- amining the way contemporary hybrid art practices exist, the scope of their activities, and how they affect other political and social practices. In the most general sense, this section will outline the position of ecological hybrid art through the lens of ecosophy. Raising awareness through excess: In Petrič’s art project, the artwork becomes an instrument for creating a non-human Other and a place for articulating relation- ships between beings, contrasting sharply with the conditions of existence under IWC.35 One interpretation of ecosophy as active social practice involves an effort to reorganize power dynamics in a way that will challenge profit-driven, exploita- tive capital accumulation and mass-media impact in shaping subjectivity. When art becomes a tool for ecosophy implementation, it integrates audiences into vital de- bates, raising awareness on shared concerns. Petrič’s excessive behaviour creates awe, imbalance, and discomfort for viewers while provoking questions about the artists’ capacity to disrupt established norms. Petrič blurs the lines between art and science, highlighting the limitations of scientific authority. Although she holds a degree in biology, she operates from the context of art, critiquing human exceptionalism by of- fering an alternative perspective, according to which plants are not merely a resource for human manipulation and experimentation. The artwork is provoking and encourages viewers to reconsider power dynam- ics among different species, inviting introspection and a critical view of constructed hierarchies.
Ecological Integration
Art as a challenge to scientific paradigms: Contemporary hybrid art practices are a powerful tool to challenge entrenched scientific paradigms. As humans ad- vance technology to preserve and facilitate survival on Earth, nature is becoming increasingly dependent on human actions. Guattari argues that natural balance will progressively rely on human intervention, necessitating programs to preserve and regulate atmospheric composition. Such artificial conditions are bound to funda- mentally alter and reshape the ecosystems’ dynamics. In Confronting Vegetal Oth- erness: Phytoteratology, this reliance on human intervention is reflected in plants’ dependence on the artist’s nurturing and breeding in artificial “wombs.” Petrič dem- onstrates in a humorous way the absurdity of scientific ethics, shaking the viewers’ faith in science and criticizing its role as an institutional practice. She does this by exemplifying that scientists are not the only ones who can conduct experiments and procreate life in laboratories. As Yves Michaud observes in his text “Art and Biotech- nology”: “We mustn’t forget that art can have a dark, transgressive dimension that does not imitate the world but rather produces a new world where values may be not only contrary to those accepted in the world, but simply incomparable.”36 Humour arises in Petrič’s work from the unexpected merging of scientific serious- ness with challenges to biological boundaries. She humanizes the plants by referring to them as her “babies,” speaking of “impossible love”37 and “plant parenthood.”38 Art’s role in shaping human perception: Beyond promoting ecological sustain- ability, hybrid art practices hold value in their ability to influence and shape human perception. Guattari emphasizes that art’s interest lies in its capacity to de-frame, breaking away from serialized, standardized meanings (“homologized” according to Pasolini) and allows those who have access to it to reinvent and resingularize themselves.39 Through transgressive behaviour and ethical, political, and moral ex- cess – founded on artistic freedom – contemporary hybrid art actively participates in shaping human perception. Petrič’s work highlights the intersection of nature and artificiality, destabilizing constructed binaries and proposing a more fluid relationship between nature and technology. This artificially created symbiosis invites alternative reflections on pow- er dynamics within ecosystems. By challenging established beliefs and viewpoints, Petrič’s work encourages viewers to perceive the world from alternative angles. By exploring alternative discourses and extending boundaries, this work of art deepens our awareness of ourselves and the external world.
When Species Meet, Donna Haraway The second hypothesis of this essay asserts the need to challenge established power structures between species, suggesting that contemporary hybrid art practices serve as a tool to demonstrate the potential for articulating alternative conceptions of multispecies sociality. Both Petrič and Haraway focus on the non-human Other, advocating for a more ethical cohabitation between humans and other species. The key point examined is how art confronts established and constructed power struc- tures and proposes alternative forms of social interaction between different species. Petrič’s project challenges traditional species hierarchies: In When Species Meet, Haraway highlights the importance of questioning conventional power dy- namics among species. She proposes alternative models of sociality and demon- strates how reshaping mental frameworks and formulating fairer policies are possi- ble. According to Haraway, the subordination of non-human others is a mental and political construction rooted in anthropocentric thinking: “My hope for companion species is that we might struggle with different demons from those produced by analogy and hierarchy linking all of fictional man’s others.”40
Ecological Integration
Companion species are figures of a relational ontology, in which histories matter, i.e. they are material, meaningful, processual, emergent, and constitutive.41 Traditionally, plants and other non-human beings have served primarily to en- hance human life, providing pleasure and comfort to human beings. Petrič’s work, however, suggests deterritorialization from anthropocentric subjectivity and accept- ance of companionship with non-human beings. Haraway explains that since there are alternative locations where reproduction processes can take place, even a partial relocation of reproductive potential has fuelled academic debates, commercial promotion of reproductive technologies, and ethical dilemmas around such processes: “Even partly relocating this power from (properly impregnated and in situ) wombs (of the same species as the being-to-be) to laboratories, clinics, embryos in freezers, stem cell collections, surrogate wombs of anomalous kinds, and genome databases has undergirded industries of academic pronouncements, commercial boosterism, and bioethical angst.”42 What Haraway is criticizing and rethinking is the formation of polarity that con- sists of human and everything else that is not human, and the impossibility to define the latter without its human counterpart: “One being becomes means to the purposes of the other, and the hu- man assumes rights in the instrument that the animal never has in “it”self. One can be somebody only if someone else is something. To be animal is exactly not to be human and vice versa.”43 The artwork proposes an alternative form of sociality among species and shows how articulating more equitable policies between plants and human beings is possible. By creating plant-human hybrids (phytopolutans), Petrič’s work confronts historical and contemporary maltreatment of plants, underscoring the need for a more ethically nuanced approach. In doing so, she proposes an alternative way of coexistence within the world. Abha Sur and Samir Sur suggest that one should consider the democratic capacity of science: “[...] it is not science but rather the social world we inhabit, of which science is a part, which will determine whether we will unleash the democratic potential of science or become mired in its dogmatic essentialisms.”44 Thus, it is art that becomes a space for embodying the democratic power of science. In When Species Meet, Haraway focuses on the co-evolution and companionship between humans and dogs, highlighting the multidimensionality of their relation- ship, with both biotechnological and social facets. She demonstrates that this rela- tion is reciprocal: “Nor have people emerged unaltered from the interactions. Rela- tions are constitutive; dogs and people are emergent as historical beings, as subjects and objects to each other, precisely through the verbs of their relating.”45 Petrič’s work advocates embracing a similarly equitable and reciprocal relation- ship with non-human world (plants), which has already been conceptualized differ- ently with regard to some companion animals. The treatment of plants differs in that they are traditionally considered beings with no subjectivity, with only instrumental value. Both, Petrič and Haraway centre their arguments on the non-human Other, proposing the cognitive framework for a reconfiguration of multispecies sociality. Both contest the culturally and socially determined representation of the natural world, constructed from an anthropocentric perspective. Petrič invites the audience to develop and demonstrate greater empathy towards the non-human Other, while Haraway urges that this issue be reconsidered in both academic discourse and everyday life. Petrič explains:
Ecological Integration
“The result of Confronting Vegetal Otherness is not to be read as a pur- suit of functional hybridity, but rather a conceptual enslavement of par- ticular capacities of plants and humans with the purpose of recogniz- ing the limits of compatibility, empathy and post-anthropocentrism.”46 Petrič’s intent is not to propose the literal creation of hybrids; rather, her work conceptually explores the possibilities of coexistence between humans and plants. In this way, contemporary hybrid art serves as a mechanism for reflecting on and pursuing strategies for mutual inhabitation among species.
How does Hybrid Art challenge environmental injustice? Artistic creation substantially contributes to changes in aesthetic and scientific paradigms (including ecological discourses), thereby significantly enriching debates on constructed systemic inequalities among different species. The following section explores the multifaceted ways in which contemporary hybrid art influences the maintenance of ecological balance. Transdisciplinarity: Artists working within hybrid art transform excessive artis- tic behaviour and provocation into a ground for aesthetic and philosophical innova- tion. In transdisciplinary research, the emphasis often lies in exceeding disciplinary boundaries. Anna Laine writes: “The continuum is fluid, but transdisciplinarity has developed from a discontent with interdisciplinarity in terms of the latter’s reconfirma- tion of the disciplinary organization of knowledge instead of moving beyond its boundaries to create synergies and new ways of working and thinking.”47 Due to its transdisciplinary nature, hybrid art not only has the capacity to change aesthetic paradigms, but also engages with other levels of society “in diverse fields such as science, economy, urban life, school, the psychiatric establishment, forms of sociability, and (as a result) each level of ecology (including, of course, preservation and reinvention of natural environments).”48 Its power lies in its capacity to confront stigmatization and normalize ethical coexistence across various groups. By adopting a transdisciplinary approach, hybrid artists question the conventions and established traditional beliefs on what constitutes art, in a way that involves the social dimension, i.e. communication and collaboration between individuals in diverse professions, such as scientists from different disciplines as well as artists. Due to this social-relational character, contemporary hybrid art creates a platform for disciplinary symbiosis. Such art has the potential to conduct inquires and incite scientific discourse regarding ethical concerns, possibly extending its influence to reconfigure scientific paradigms. Hybrid art practices engage critically with power structures: Contemporary hy- brid art has the capacity to disrupt, through artistic provocation and transgression, the prevailing narratives that justify exploitation and environmental abuse. In her book The Art and Science of Innovation: Transdisciplinary Work, Learning and Transgression, Lor- raine White-Hancock relates the notion of transgression to crossing boundaries: “The idea of ‘transgression’ is associated with movement across boundaries. This movement becomes visible as transgression relative to particular social norms and identities.”49 By taking nonconformist and alternate perspectives on ordinary and established discours- es, hybrid art practices confront hegemonic power configurations and their dynamics. Both science and technology, when in the service of dominant ideologies and power mechanisms, can be subjected to artistic subversion and transgression, but subversive and transgressive art can also derive support from science and technology.
Ecological Integration
“[...] the aesthetic paradigm does not solely derive from artistic crea- tion, even if renewed artistic creation can fundamentally contribute to its change and the emergence of a new trend in diverse fields such as science, economy, urban life, school, the psychiatric establishment, forms of sociability, and (as a result) each level of ecology (including, of course, preservation and reinvention of natural environments).”50 Participatory potential of hybrid art: It is not only for the purpose of artistic production, but also for the realization of artworks by virtue of participation, that contemporary hybrid art practices often involve relational aspects to other commu- nity members. Many ecological hybrid art projects incorporate participatory meth- odology, fostering community engagement, collective action, knowledge-sharing, etc. Ecological hybrid art projects massively integrate local communities into vari- ous stages of creation and this inclusion plays a significant role in raising environ- mental awareness. In her book Artificial Hells: Participatory Art and the Politics of Spectatorship, Claire Bishop explains that “[...] today’s participatory art is often at pains to emphasize process over a definitive image, concept or object. It tends to value what is invisible: a group dynamic, a social situation, a change of energy, a raised consciousness.”51 Even if a work of art is not directly participatory, references to community, collectivity (be this lost or actualised), and revolution are sufficient to indicate a critical distance towards the neoliberal new world order.52 Bishop is mak- ing a binary distinction between social and artistic discourse: “The social discourse accuses the artistic discourse of amorality and in- efficacy, because it is insufficient merely to reveal, reduplicate, or reflect upon the world; what matters is social change. The artistic discourse accuses the social discourse of remaining stubbornly attached to exist- ing categories, and focusing on micropolitical gestures at the expense of sensuous immediacy as a potential locus of disalienation.”53 Nonetheless, there have been multiple examples in contemporary hybrid art practices (as well as in other art practices) that demonstrate how social and artistic discourses intermingle to form a single discourse. As in this particular case, artists engage with different fields of knowledge such as biology, biotechnology, ecology, ecofeminism, etc., to examine and discuss various aspects of society, challenging the boundaries between artistic and social discourses to create a unified voice. Critique of anthropocentrism: Just like any other natural ecosystem, the one that Petrič has created is influenced by humans, yet here, a human being is in the service of plants, nurturing the plant embryos with hormones derived from human urine. Through this work, Petrič humorously suggests an alternative way of human existence with non-human beings. The project foregrounds the integrity of plants and challenges the belief that human beings alone possess intrinsic value and are, as such, superior to other organisms. Reimagining human-plant relationships: Petrič’s project departs from the tra- ditional perceptions and articulations of the correlation between two opposite enti- ties, i.e. human and non-human. This polarity has been a long-established paradigm that needs to be restructured. Through artistic provocation and excess, Petrič chal- lenges the conventional methods of plant breeding for the purpose of artistic ex- periment, unlike the breeding of cultures for their instrumental purpose. Here, plant embryos are cultivated in artificial “wombs” and nurtured with hormones derived from the artist’s urine. Plants are thus deterritorialized from their natural way of cultivation, as they embrace a fluid and transformative relation with non-plants by being cultivated in artificial “wombs”, which is a feature specific to the reproductive
Ecological Integration
behaviour in mammals. Nurturing plant embryos with hormones derived from the artist’s urine embodies an alternative type of ecosystem, where energy and matter are transferred from one organism to another in an artificial way. In other words, the energy transfer is initiated and mediated by humans. The artist demonstrates that thinking in binary logic, which treats culture as the opposite of nature, has reached a stage where it requires profound reconsideration. Art as exploration of ecological interconnectedness: Petrič’s work highlights the interdependence and reciprocity of humans and plants within an ecological system. This symbiotic interaction is achieved in an artificial way, through technol- ogy. The artist emphasizes the immensity of human impact on the natural world. By adopting bioart techniques and advanced technologies, the artist challenges anthropocentric views that prioritize human needs, advocating for the manner of thinking of the environment more integratively. Her work is directed towards discursive relativization and contests anthropocentrism as a dominant belief ac- cording to which intrinsic value is reserved for human beings while the value of non-human beings depends on their potential to contribute to human well-being. Using an artistic intervention that implies the modification of natural processes, Petrič refutes the anthropocentric paradigm and encourages an egalitarian per- spective on interspecies exchange and a dynamic evolution of human relationship with the non-human world. Art pointing at ethical considerations: Eco-artists are at liberty to employ im- agination, vision, wit, humour, exaggeration, ridicule, glorification, and every other expressive means that artistic license allows.54 It has been clearly acknowledged that contemporary hybrid art has assumed the role of a social practice that highlights and criticizes environmental injustice. As Wolek writes: “The beginnings of ecologi- cal art took place in the 1960s, at the time when publications about the disastrous state of the Earth began to appear. The art can be treated as a sign of the awakening of ecological awareness.”55 In their text “Labs Shut Open: A Biotech Hands-on Workshop for Artists,” Oron Catts and Garry Cass point out: “As our knowledge and abilities to manipulate life increase, so does the need to make sense of where we are going. Art can play an impor- tant role in creating cultural meaning and informed involvement that are needed in order for our society to comprehend the very significant changes we are facing.”56 Petrič’s work exemplifies how art practices can subvert science’s role in envi- ronment exploitation, profit-driven activities, and neoliberal capitalism in gen- eral. In such a transdisciplinary setting, art’s power lies in its ability to question the role and position of science in contemporary world and criticize the institu- tionalization of science. By confronting the audience with transgressive situations and peculiarity, an artwork can reach the viewers on an individual level, pro- voking them directly into critically considering their own attitudes towards the environment, thus raising awareness about the mechanisms of exploitation and the relations of dominance and inferiority between the human and non-human worlds. Antonioli writes: “Guattari raises a very good point when he claims that [...] the art- ist is some sort of ‘wandering knight’ who aims towards heterogen- esis (in opposition to capitalistic homogeny); against the simplifica- tion of money as a universal equivalent, art can ensure diversity and singularity.”57
Ecological Integration
Conclusion This essay has explored how contemporary hybrid art practices strive to redefine their purpose towards balancing political and ecological structures, thereby bringing societal and environmental concerns to light and advocating for the destabilization of anthropocentric viewpoint. The first hypothesis is that Guattari’s concept of ecosophy provides a theoretical basis for the development and implementation of hybrid art strategies. Ecosophy provides a foundation that hybrid art practices embody and materialize through their strategies and procedures. Primary considerations analysed in this paper ad- dress the following considerations: 1) art’s capacity to raise awareness of environ- mental injustice through excess, 2) art’s challenge to the traditional scientific and anthropocentric paradigm, 3) art’s role in fostering connections between humans and their environment, and 4) art’s participation in shaping human perception be- yond merely promoting ecological sustainability. The second hypothesis emphasizes the necessity of questioning established power hierarchies among species, positing that contemporary hybrid art demon- strates how alternative models of multispecies sociality are possible. Both Špela Petrič and Donna Haraway focus on the non-human Other, aiming to reimagine the forms of sociality between the human and non-human worlds. Consequently, hybrid art advocates for fairer, more balanced relationships between human and non-human beings, and for ethical coexistence at the intersection of the artificial and the natural, prompting a reconfiguration of power relations. Key points sup- porting the second hypothesis include: 1) that hybrid art challenges traditional power hierarchies among species, and 2) that it proposes new forms of sociality among species. The final considerations regarding contemporary hybrid art’s influence on envi- ronmental injustice include:
1) Transdisciplinary influence: Hybrid art not only has the capacity to re- shape aesthetic paradigms but also engages broadly with other levels of so- ciety – “in diverse fields such as science, economy, urban life, school, the psychiatric establishment, forms of sociability, and (as a result) each level of ecology (including, of course, preservation and reinvention of natural environments).”58
2) Critical engagement with power structures: Hybrid art practices challenge hegemonic power structures and their mechanisms, adopting alternative per- spectives that disrupt established narratives.
3) Participatory potential: By extending beyond traditional notions of artistic production, contemporary hybrid art involves the audience relationally, en- couraging community engagement and collective action.
4) Enhanced accessibility: Hybrid art’s inclination towards technology expands its reach to wider audiences via digital social media platforms.
In The Ethics of Earth Art, Boetzkes argues that “[...] art has a part to play in critiquing the ways we frame nature through representation as well as through sci- ence and technology. Moreover, it does so by forging an aesthetic awareness of how nature exceeds these discourses and representations.”59 Contemporary artists draw from various disciplines including biology, ecology, and bioethics, aiming to make an impact not only within the artworld, but also in
Ecological Integration
the broader societal sphere. By challenging dominant paradigms and prevailing nar- ratives, artists create alternative discourses and ways of existence. By questioning their own place and role in the world, as well as the place of science, hybrid art prac- tices shape human perceptions and attitudes, fostering a holistic approach to human coexistence with non-human living beings.
NOTES 1 MIŠKO ŠUVAKOVIĆ, Pojmovnik suvremene umjetnosti, Zagreb, Aesthetics, Politics, Environments and Epistemologies (eds. Heath- Horetzky, 2005, 157. er Davis and Etienne Turpin), London, Open Humanities Press, 2 VLADIMIR FILIPOVIĆ, Filozofski riječnik, Zagreb, Nakladni za- 2015, 349. vod Matice hrvatske, 1989, 253. 13 HEATHER DAVIS (note 12), 350. 3 VLADIMIR FILIPOVIĆ (note 2), 254. 14 AMANDA BOETZKES, The Ethics of Earth Art, Minneapolis 4 CHANTAL MOUFFE, On the Political, London and New York, and London, University of Minnesota Press, 2010, 104. Routledge, 2005, 9. 15 PETER SLOTERDIJK (note 11), 328. 5 The term apparatus refers to a set of concepts introduced by 16 Ibidem. Guattari. 17 Ibidem. 6 https://www.spelapetric.org/phytoteratology (last accessed on April 18 Ibidem. 30, 2024). 19 Ibidem. 7 https://www.spelapetric.org/phytoteratology (last accessed on April 30, 2024). 20 Ibidem. 8 https://www.spelapetric.org/phytoteratology (last accessed on Octo- 21 FELIX GUATTARI, The Three Ecologies, London, and New Brun- ber 23, 2024). swick, The Athlone Press, 2000, 4-5. 9 https://www.spelapetric.org/phytoteratology (last accessed on Octo- 22 Ibid., 28. ber 23, 2024). 23 Ibidem. 10 In her doctoral dissertation, “Modalities of Extreme, Excessive, 24 MANOLA ANTONIOLI, What is Ecosophy, in: Schizoanalysis Radical, and Extravagant Contemporary Visual Art Practices” and Ecosophy, Reading Deleuze and Guattari (ed. Constantin V. Sunčica Ostoić develops a concept of “exaggeration,” which she Boundas), London, New York, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 75. distinguishes from “excess” and “transgression.” 25 IAN PINDAR and PAUL SUTTON, Translators’ Introduction, 11 PETER SLOTERDIJK, The Anthropocene: A Process-State at in: The Three Ecologies by Felix Guattari (note 10), 4-5. the Edge of Geohistory?, in: Art in the Anthropocene Encounters 26 AMANDA BOETZKES (note 14), 8. Among Aesthetics, Politics, Environments and Epistemologies (eds. 27 FELIX GUATTARI (note 21), 52. Heather Davis and Etienne Turpin), London, Open Humanities Press, 2015, 329. 28 AMANDA BOETZKES (note 14), 1-2. 12 HEATHER DAVIS, Life & Death in the Anthropocene: A Short 29 MANOLA ANTONIOLI (note 24), 6. History of Plastic, in: Art in the Anthropocene Encounters Among 30 FELIX GUATTARI (note 21), 61.
Ecological Integration
31 Ibid., 44. 45 DONNA HARAWAY (note 40), 62. 32 Ibid., 64. 46 https://www.spelapetric.org/scotopoiesis (last accessed on April 33 Ibid., 50. 22, 2024). 47 ANNA LAINE, Practicing Art and Anthropology: A Transdisci- 34 Ibidem. plinary Journey, London and New York, Bloomsbury Academic, 35 In Guattari’`s book The Three Ecologies, the abbreviation IWC 2018, 16. stands for Integrated World Capitalism. IWC exercises control 48 MANOLA ANTONIOLI (note 24), 77. over people by means of mass media and its impact is exerted in environmental, social, and mental ecological registers. 49 LORRAINE WHITE-HANCOCK, The Art and Science of In- novation: Transdisciplinary Work, Learning and Transgression, 36 YVES MICHAUD, Art and Biotechnology, in: Signs of Life: Bio Cham, Springer, 2023, 19. Art and Beyond (ed. Eduardo Kac), Cambridge, MA and Lon- 50 MANOLA ANTONIOLI (note 24), 77. don, The MIT Press, 2007, 394. 51 CLAIRE BISHOP, Artificial Hells: Participatory Art and the Poli- 37 https://www.spelapetric.org/phytoteratology (last accessed on Oc- tics of Spectatorship, London and New York, Verso, 2012, 6. tober 27, 2024). 52 CLAIRE BISHOP (note 51), 12. 38 https://www.spelapetric.org/phytoteratology (last accessed on Oc- 53 Ibid., 276. tober 27, 2024). 54 LINDA WEINTRAUB, Introduction to Environmental Art, in: 39 MANOLA ANTONIOLI (note 24), 77. To Life! Eco Art in Pursuit of a Sustainable Planet, Oakland, CA, 40 DONNA HARAWAY, When Species Meet, Minneapolis, MN and University of California Press, 2012, 3. London, 2008, 309. 55 MAGDALENA WOLEK, Ecological Art and its Main Thesis, Sci- 41 DONNA HARAWAY, The Haraway Reader, New York and Lon- entific Papers of Silesian University of Technology, 141 (2019), 432. don, Routledge, 2004, 307. 56 ORON CATTS and GARRY CASS, Labs Shut Open: A Biotech 42 DONNA HARAWAY (note 40), 138-139. Hands-on Workshop for Artists, in: Tactical Biopolitics: Art, Ac- 43 Ibid., 206. tivism, and Technoscience (ed. Beatriz da Costa, Kavita Philip), Cambridge, MA and London, The MIT Press, 2008, 143. 44 ABHA SUR and SAMIR SUR, In Contradiction Lies the Hope: Human Genome and Identity Politics, in: Tactical Biopolitics: 57 MANOLA ANTONIOLI (note 24), 77. Art, Activism, and Technoscience (ed. Beatriz da Costa, Kavita 58 Ibidem. Philip), Cambridge, MA and London, The MIT Press, 2008, 215. 59 AMANDA BOETZKES (note 14), 2.
The work is published under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0), which enables reusers to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon the material in any medium or format, so long as attribution is given to the creator. The license allows for commercial use: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.