Preskoči na sadržaj
Revista de Historia del Arte Adriático Traži

Moć praznine - Spekulativni realizam i umjetnički radovi Tome Savića Gecana

DOI 10.15291/ars.525

Preuzmi PDF

Svezak 5 (2015)

Otvoreni pristup

Metrike članka

  • 3 412 Pregledi sažetka
  • 1 248 Preuzimanja PDF-a
  • 12 Preuzimanja po danu
  • 164 Preuzimanja ovaj mjesec
Fundamentalna teza moje rasprave glasi: djela Tome Savića Gecana su zasnovana na konceptu da je um promatrača orijentiran ka vanjskim predmetima. Ako su vanjski predmeti prazni, tada su oni indeksne struktureza mentalne konstrukcije. Tomo Savić Gecan je hrvatsko-holandski umjetnikčija se umjetnička praksa formirala početkom i sredinom devedesetih godina dvadesetog stoljeća. On se pojavio na zagrebačkoj umjetničkoj sceni s tada mladim umjetnicima koji otkrivaju kulturalne tragove kao mediji svog umjetničkog rada. Njego rad se tada bitno razlikovao od ostalih umjetnika njegove generacije po tome što je izvodio događaje radikalnog minimalističkog i apercpetivno kritičkog redukcionizma. Reducirao je čulnost umjetničkog djela na intencionalno indeksiranje potencijalnosti umjetničkog djela na popozicijskoindeksne intervencije u prostoru, vremenu i ponašanju unutar, najčešće galerijskog života. Dok se većina umjetnika hrvatskoga neokonceptualizma sredinom devedesetih godina bavila eksplicitnim kulturalnim značenjima i njihovim distribucijama posredstvom masovnih medija prikazivanja ili potrošnje, Tomo Savić Gecan je radio s izoliranim uzrocima, neprimjetnim događajima, neutraliziranim intenzitetima, odloženim posljedicama i razrađenim indeksacijama nositelja značenja unutar kulturalnih institucimja i njihovioh prostorno-vremenskih situacija u ljudskom životu. Drugim riječima, postmediji umjetničkih radova Tome Savića Gecana nisu kulturalne reprezentacije, već prostorne, vremenske i bihevioralne pojavnosti kulturalnih institucija u odnosu na tijelo/ponašanje promatrača, gledatelja ili sudionika u projektu. On je eksplicitno radio s body/mind modelima situiranjadogađaja u čulni svijet nasuprot ili izvan naglašene čulnosti. Mnogostruki konceptualni i čulno-pojavni događaji odsutnosti i praznine u umjetnost su se odigravali tijekom dugog dvadesetog stoljeća. Ti događaji su se izvodili odlaganjem, premještanjem pražnjenjem, razlučivanjem te indeksiranjem izuzetnosti bivanja tu i tada. Ali, izvođeni su i isticanjem granične-minimalne prisutnosti, retoričnošću praznog, ponovljivošću neutralnog,odstupanjem, oduzimanjem precrtavanjem, redukcijom oblika, preobražajem simbola u znak i znaka u mjesto odsutnosti i odlaganja, tj. u sam označitelj.
Tomo Savić Gecan, snaga praznine, object-mind, instalacija, indeks, događaj, izvan
Odjeljci
  1. Sažetak
  2. Bilješke

Certain artists have entered the adventure of search for emptiness preceding and following every act of life: human productive reproduction the society. In different historical periods, those artists – Savić Gecan included – have obsessively, persistently and dramatically confronted the powers of emptiness within social and cultural institutions, apparatuses and situations. Tomo Savić Gecan started investigating the empty at the time of artistic reflections following the eclectic postmodernism of the 1980s or, more precisely, at the time of the so-called art in the ‘of culture.’ Tomo Savić Gecan’s works, installations and performances brought forth in this context even though they were with standard art production of that time. His production differs from practices based on media representations and performances referring to or rooted in and cultural conditions and circumstances. Gecan’s work is different through displacement, absence, totalizing minimalism and exception from fictional contexts of ordinary life featuring unexpected instruments of intervention. This paper argues that Tomo Savić Gecan’s artworks are based on the idea that the spectator’s mind is oriented towards external objects. If such objects are empty, then they become indexing structures for mental constructions.

1. Philosophical Remarks: Direct Experience Instabilities cause contingent motion in undeter- mined directions. The relationship between motion and The foundation of my argument is the following: non-motion, the visible and the invisible acquire signifi- Tomo Savić Gecan’s artworks are based on the idea that cance: invisible motion, conspicuous non-motion and a the spectator mind is oriented1 towards external objects. hint of a potential change. A change may cause a catas- If such objects are empty, then they become indexing trophe, yet the catastrophe never happens, merely the structures for mental constructions. minimal, almost neutral diversions, displacements and Minimal changes in the outside2 state of things. Trans- lapses from the ordinary experienced reality of normal parent situations set up in the outside world of corporeal, life and standard perception. sensuous existence. Minimal displacements between the The ordinary experienced reality is, in fact, a nor- visible and invisible events in the world of objects and mal reality which consists of relationships between the spatial relationships invoke effects, intensities and conse- incidental and perpetual with regard to as opposed to quences of disturbance. Disturbance is a means to a situ- the visible and the invisible. The incidental is expected ation. Uncertainty regarding the stability of relationships while the perpetual does not follow a pattern or a law. between objects, spaces, time intervals and social func- Rather, it comes from the mystery of the miraculous.3 tions. Creation of a sense of uncertainty and instability Everything happens at zero level which suggests that in the situations claimed by public institutions, mostly nothing ever happened. However, although nothing is institutions of everyday life of culture: a gallery, a park, a ever the same, it is as if everything remained the same. museum, a shopping mall. Contradictions lie in one’s experience and contrasts in

Miško Šuvaković: The Power of the Void, Speculative Realism... Ars Adriatica 5/2015. (193-202)

1996 St. Toma Gallery, Rovinj 2000 Manifesta 3, Modern Gallery, Ljubljana Otok / Island, Dubrovnik One of the walls invisibly moves and fills in the Iron railings, of the type used as barriers between space. the pavement and the road were constructed. The railings were first exhibited in St. Toma gallery in Rovinj on a solo exhibition. vated event appears as a challenge to the ordinary, normal In the second stage, the same railings where stability of the subject. What takes place escapes percep- installed on the road in Dubrovnik in the tion and conceals its cause. What actually occurs is the primary function. confounding of transparent relationships between causes, events and consequences in the observer’s experience. The essential and determining ignorance and inexpe- the feelings of one’s position in the world. The world is rience lead the subject into a situation of fear, into an al- uncertain and unstable. most imperceptible isolation. An illusion of autism. Au- Being uncertain about the primary and immediate tism as a refuge from the dangers of the outside world. human experience of existence (Daßsein). What is sug- A metaphor of autism rather than a simulation of it. The gested is a sense of fear but not the fear itself. The ab- world is alien to the subject, whoever he/she might be, sence of panic. A fear that comes not from something or does not accept it. The subject feels insecure in the situ- someone, but from the uncertainty of the barely noticea- ations created by the artist, that is, the interventions by ble infinite possibilities of displacement and transforma- Tomo Savić Gecan, which cause the subject to develop a tions of situations in the world as a whole or in the frag- sense of insecurity-incapability to use phantasm5 in or- ments of the world which are difficult to assemble. The der to situate, locate, determine or conceive human exist- displacement into an unknown situation which resem- ence in relation to the outside world in the here and now. bles a familiar one. The fear which is not grounded in the There is no sacrifice, no heroic act, no nocturnal de- experience that verifies our knowledge of the mechanism mons, no horror, no uncanny abjections,6 phantoms, in of life’s events. fact, there are no daily demons either and no sublime… The ordinary human everyday empiricism is subvert- What is performed is a relationship/situation consisting ed. This is not a panic fear or anxiety about the future of a barely perceptible insecurity in one’s own senses, and but the uncertainty of the ability to grasp empirically in the rationalization of available relationships between what happens or happened in a specific time and place the experience of the senses and the acts of one’s con- – in the here and now. An intricate web of the visible sciousness/body. and invisible aspects, relationships, roles and functions The situation is open and uncertain… Something discourages the observer/participant from relying on his/ lapses and in so doing indicates a void, a deferral (diffé- her verified experience and to rationalize, explain, and rance)7 or something that precedes language (Ursprung), present events in an obvious way. Something is missing something that does not conform to the rules of prag- there and then, and what has been missing is an essential matic daily operations among the people and for the peo- determinant for being in the world at that singular mo- ple connected to the institutions of culture and society. ment and that singular spot4. The thing (das Ding) which gives meaning to an event A situation is set: displacements in space and time are is absent. The situation is set through minimal displace- nothing but tactical operations or performances. It is as if ments, lapses, recesses and deferrals, that is, through everything has its own in place while minor lapses render invisible or concealed causal bonds connecting what is the order of the micro-world or the macro-world danger- normally not connected into a sequence of cause and ous, almost detrimental to the awareness about the pres- consequence. It seems as if nothing happened: the neu- ence of the observer/participant in the world. An unmoti- trality is overwhelming. Yet, nothing is the same and in- difference is replaced by a sense of fear which becomes 1997 Dunaujvaros, Hungary, Institute of confusion and, finally, a sensation of being afloat and Contemporary Art: Who by Fire # 1 dislocated from the world. Is the existence of the world at stake here? On the ground plan of the gallery a fictional A triumph of a performed indifferent abstraction in mental space was drawn. the world of habits, customs, normality, contract and, above all, visibility, transparency, and spectacularity.

2. Aesthetic Remarks: Who, When and Where? The Fasci- In other words, the media of Gecan’s work are not nation with Absence and the Void: The Anti-Metaphysics cultural representations but spatial, temporal and behav- of the Real ioural phenomena experienced in the context of cultural institutions by the spectators, viewers or participants in a This is an essay about an artist who is concerned with project. He explicitly engages with the body/mind models creating absence or setting up a void in the world of ob- of situating events in the world of the senses as opposed jects and human relationships. He causes disturbances in to, or even going beyond, exaggerated sensuousness. the causal chain of events within the contemporary sys- Many conceptual and phenomenal events that had to tem of art, culture and life. He works with galleries, mu- do with the ‘absence’ and the ‘void’ were developed dur- seums and other public spaces, which he uses for staging ing the twentieth century. These events were performed barely perceptible events, as zero-degree experiences. through deferral, displacement, discharging, distinction I met Tomo Savić Gecan for the first time in February and indexing of the exclusivity of being here and now. of 1997 in the Hungarian industrial town of Dunaújváros.8 In addition, they were characterized by the emphasis on At the town’s Institute of Contemporary Art, he created a the liminal-minimal presence, the rhetoric of emptiness, ‘mental performance’ based on an act of conscience which the perpetuity of the neutral, by the digression, appro- suggested the relocation of a gallery office into the space priation, crossing out and the reduction of form, by the of the gallery itself. The act of conscience was indexed9 transformation of symbols into signs, and of signs into by marking the coordinates of the space that was relo- points of absence and deferral, that is, into mere signi- cated. The barely visible intentional operation is marked fiers. A signifier being: and promised in a suggestive way. Vision is subordinated to an act of imaginary rendering. The Cognitive Event is … the signifier for which all the other signifiers rep- equivalent to spatial indexing,10 for example, the point ‘S’ resent the subject: that is to say, in the absence of this was relocated and placed onto the point ‘T’. signifier, all the other signifiers represent nothing, Tomo Savić Gecan is a Croatian-Dutch artist whose since nothing is represented only for something else. artistic practices were formed in the early and the mid- What represents the subject for all other signifiers.12 1990s. He appeared in the art scene of Zagreb together with a generation of young artists who showed ‘cultural The negative metaphysics of absence and void is a traces’ as the media of their artistic work.11 Gecan’s work great challenge posed by the twentieth-century century of that time differed essentially from that of the rest of the art to the dawning of the twenty-first century. artists of his generation in that he performed events which Marcel Duchamp elaborated on the concept of the belonged to the category of a radical, minimalist and aper- readymade by referring to an aesthetic anaesthesia: ceptive critical reductionism. He reduced the sensuousness of an artwork to the intentional indexing of its potentiality, This choice was based on a reaction of visual indif- and the intentionality of an artwork to the propositional ference with at the same time a total absence of good indexing of interventions in the space, time and behaviour and bad taste… in fact a complete anaesthesia.13 in the context of a gallery. Unlike the majority of Croatian neo-conceptualists of the mid 1990s who featured explicit By confronting white with white, Malevich advanced cultural significations and their dissemination by means of the idea of supremacy14 as a ‘pure’ experience of the thing the mass media of representation or consumption, Tomo itself, as if a painting had become an effect and the inten- Savić Gecan worked with isolated causes, imperceptible sity of that effect. Ad Reinhardt15 ended his search for the events, neutralized intensities, deferred consequences and ultimate limit of a painting and of painting as such, in elaborated indexations of the bearers of meaning within the zone between the pictorial and the conceptual. Yves cultural institutions and their spatial-temporal situations. Klein reached beyond the appearance of material objects and attempted to present the void itself so that it can be experienced as an absence that is displayed in a spectac- 2001 20 years of the PM Gallery; House of ular way. Piero Manzoni centred the gaze on the traces Croatian Artist, Dubrovnik, Art Galler of his human existence by exhibiting his own breath, fin- 2006 On Mobility, De Appel, Amsterdam gerprints, canned excrement, inscriptions on a woman’s body... The painter Julije Knifer depicted absence and Each gallery visitor sets the ticket price for the void in an allegorical monotonous repetition of a sign next visitor. which, through a denial of progress or development in painting, disclosed the power of the void: that what is

Miško Šuvaković: The Power of the Void, Speculative Realism... Ars Adriatica 5/2015. (193-202)

formance, that is, the corporeal, institutional, productive, 2003 Portal II, Kunsthalle Fridericianum, Kassel meditative, activist, creative or destructive artistic prac- tices of the long twentieth century. 1. a continuous registration of visitors movements 2. this registration will define changes in 3. Ontological Remarks: Negative Ontology of Tomo Savić architecture elsewhere Gecan’s Work

What is absence? Or, rather, how does one represent beyond the visible. The American painter Robert Ry- or display the void? man explored sequences of painting at a zero degree of A significant difference exists between what is rep- pictorial writing – the white script of painting. Indexing resented and what is displayed and it requires further the entropy of the soil, the geological strata or the lay- elaboration. ers of detritus, Robert Smithson indicated the visibility Absence is that which is not here. Absence is that of disappearance. Entropy was a medium through which which is not present. The void, however, is that which he recorded the worlds which vanished in the geologi- cannot be thought of! That which is neither here and cal process of layering. Sol LeWitt provoked the visible now not there. That which is absent is that which is dis- world of modern art with conceptual fetishes of the in- placed. The void is that which does not contain anything. visible – he once wrote that ‘even a blind man can make The void exists in the here and now but is without those art.’16 The South African conceptual artist Ian Wilson things. Absence is that which is not here and this ‘not instead of displaying the visual, offered a speech about being here’ includes time, a time of deferral. the invisibility of linguistic narrative in the space of the Questions about absence and the void are questions gallery. Goran Trbuljak demonstrated that an institution about the active illusion of a ‘negative core’ which lies at was self-sufficient: a gallery can exist even without art, the heart of meaning. The concept of an ‘empty or absent that is, an exhibition in a renowned gallery is more im- core’, which is not subject to the laws of symbolization but portant than what is on display: anything can be put on which nonetheless regulates symbolization, was conceived display. Anish Kapoor sculpted an ancient Indian ‘habi- through a reflection about the fragility of the human sub- tat’ for the void that fills a space. Anna Mendieta per- ject when it comes to shaping or living life and about hu- formed an act of absence of her own body with regard manity between the symbolic and the non-symbolic. to the location of potential presence, it was as if she lo- Can absence and the void be experienced and how? cated the ritual emptiness of the grave. Anthony Gorm- The paradox of experience lies in the fact that expe- ley recorded the traces of the body through his imprints rience is a product, a remnant, debris, a shaving, a trace in the solid material of the sculpture. Rachel Whiteread of participation or compliance which acquires meaning filled the emptiness of a house and underlined the void through symbolization. What results from this is that sym- in architecture. Cindy Sherman repeated the rhetorical bolization is nothing but interpretation. Experience ap- role of a pose and through this divested the display of pears as a pre-remnant, a surplus which becomes part of her masked behavioural body of psychological motiva- culture only through symbolization: a surplus of a visible tion. In the last works before her death, Hannah Wilke human life for other human lives. In contrast to this, expe- attempted to grasp and reveal the visibility of the void rience itself escapes symbolization. An experience which is of death. Vadim Fishkin connected his heartbeats to the identified within a culture, however, remains the product light-emitting system of a lighthouse and through this of the very symbolization which situates it in human lives. outlined a thin border between the absence and presence Nevertheless, the human world as a world of meaning of human existence. Felix Gonzales-Torres explored the is shaped around this ‘empty’ and ‘absent’ experience. It is expiration and termination in a body which escapes life a world of an endless supply of images – representations – through the loss of immunity and his work is marked which are saturated with meaning and which conceals their by emptying the space of a gallery, depriving galleries of true nature. The true nature being the void and absence. artworks and so on… An example. The sensory externalization and display These are quite varied instances of the anticipation of of accumulated horror caused by a destruction of ordi- effects – actions and intensities – from the absent and nary human affairs manifested themselves in the real- the void, to the deferred and the erased … The multi- time, that is, live media (TV, Internet) broadcasts about plicity of the absent and the void was brought about in the 9/11 terrorist attacks in the US or the 2004 tsunami completely different contexts of painting, sculpture, per- disaster in southeast Asia, but also in the numerous me-

dia coverage and assessments of the genocides commit- tion in space ‘Y’. What goes on cannot be seen or empiri- ted in Africa and Europe during the 1990s. These events cally apprehended. Two completely separate events. The shook the world not only because they were real but two events cannot be connected with each other through because they were almost instantly reported through the experience of the people who came for an exhibition audio-visual broadcasts and so brought the global audi- launch in Utrecht or in of the people who went shopping ences face to face with human tragedies and suffering. in a mall at Zagreb. The two events became connected The idea of ‘witnessing’ was made real by representing only through the external intervention of the artist who the impossible experience of those who were involved established the possibility for the contingency between directly in the catastrophe such as a crime or violence, ‘W’ and ‘Y’. The artist’s intervention connected the event through images and a meaningful interpretation which ‘W’ in Utrecht with the event ‘Y’ in Zagreb by means of was generated by a symbolic order. a technical hardware/software relationship. It emerged as Historic accounts of floods, earthquakes or battles a performance and a performed relationship between the have always been mediated17. With live satellite and inter- two geographical locations and cultural venues. With- net communication everything has become almost here out this intervention-as-event and event-as-potential- and now, and present in a plausible way. In addition, new interpretation, the relationship between ‘W’ and ‘Y’ was and all-encompassing media spectacles represent a spe- unrepresentable. The artist consciously claimed, that is, cific tactic aimed at an instant processing of documen- occupied the space of the missing contingency, and by tary footage which renders temporal and spatial distance this, informed us that something happened to someone relative. News about disasters in the previous centuries else. Yet, that someone cannot grasp from his or her own reached the interested audience, that is, members of a experience what happened to his or her there and then. given culture with a delay. For instance, Théodore Géri- Now, imagine an analogous story, almost a fairy tale! cault painted The Raft of the Medusa two to three years There is a girl or a boy, let’s say, a boy who lives some- after the incident. The public saw it four years later. On where in Northern Europe. He decided to work hard for the other hand, the broadcasts of the demolition of the the whole year, for example in a bank, to be able to fulfil his World Trade Center or the tsunami reached us within a dream. He works every day, seven days a week. He works couple of hours, that is, almost instantly. A student from extra hours and weekends. He puts aside every cent he has the Balkans recounted that his parents in Southeast Eu- saved. He knows that this is for what he wants the most. He rope found out about the WTC attack before him even wants a summer holiday on a faraway warm seashore on though he was on the New York subway just a few stops the other side of the world. He wants freedom. He wants to from the WTC. The new media spectacles compress time be alone somewhere far away. The day has finally come: the and space and combine fact and fiction into public, all- ‘D-Day’! His agency booked a two-week vacation in a top- encompassing and in most cases broadcasted events. class, five-star hotel on an anonymous island. The endless Tomo Savić Gecan conceives experience as being im- sandy beaches, the mesmerizing sea, the… He daydreams perceptible which is opposed to the spectacular nature of of a faraway beach at the end of the world. He takes a non- an impossible experience wrapped in meaning and sense. stop, twelve-hour flight. He snoozes, sips a cocktail, chats An imperceptible experience was part of his project Un- with the stewardesses. He closes and then opens his eyes titled (Utrecht – Zagreb, 2001) in which he linked two and sees the palm trees on the island of happiness. He is apparently unconnected events: relaxed. He is content. He reaches the island. A hotel cabby meets him at the airport and drives him along the seaside. 1) the entry of visitors to the exhibition Common The endless ocean, the palm trees and elephants on the Ground in the Gallery Begane Grond in Utrecht, and other side. The scent of freedom. His suite overlooks the 2) the stopping of the escalators at the Kaptol Centar shopping mall in Zagreb18.

The performance established a relationship between 2004 Isabella Bortolozzi Gallery, Berlin two geographical points – cities – in Europe: Utrecht and Zagreb. There is no contingency between the events at The passing of visitors during the Portal 2 these two points; therefore, there is no chain of events, exhibition in Kunsthalle Fridericianum, Kassel such as the situation ‘W’ in Utrecht caused an event ‘Y’, that is a change somewhere in Zagreb. Instead, the art- (XII 2003-II 2004) causes small changes in the ist established an artificial relationship between the two architecture in Isabella Bortolozzi Gallery, Berlin cities characterized by an impossible and absurd contin- (XI 2004-I 2005). gency. A motion taking place in space ‘W’ causes a mo-

Miško Šuvaković: The Power of the Void, Speculative Realism... Ars Adriatica 5/2015. (193-202)

ject participating in an event or the subjects who claim 2005 La Biennale di Venezia, Venezia or acquire the role of ‘external others’, those who learn about something that has happened to someone else in During the 51. Biennale di Venezia visitors a specific time and place by investigating. The reality of to W139 Center for Contemporary Art in their respective experiences lacks the symbolic represen- Amsterdam, The Netherlands, change the tation of the one who experienced the actual event… To temperature of the water in the Spordiklubi him or her, this is the inconceivable emptiness (death, Reval-Sport in Tallinn, Estonia by 1°C. madness, fear, confusion, disorientation, inertia, neglect, random stopping of the escalators). Symbolic representation acquires meaning only in the ocean. He takes a shower, puts on a new shirt and white eyes of the subject outside the event who, by his or her linen trousers. He sits at a hotel terrace bar, slowly sipping a intricacies of symbolization represents, interprets, grasps colourful cocktail. This is the real thing. Dancing all night at or even experiences something that does not have a neces- the club just for himself, he feels other people’s gazes on his sary mode of symbolization to the person who found him- dancing body. This night is his only, he does not want other self or herself at a particular moment in time surrounded nights and does not want to share this night with others. by nothingness of experience. It is as if there is no differ- It is as if he has never worked in that bloody bank. After- ence between the boy in the story and a casual visitor to wards he falls into a deep sleep until the morning. Twitter- the exhibition in Utrecht or the shopping mall in Zagreb: ing birds and the sound of the waves wake him. He goes to what happened, what they experienced – the pain and the beach before breakfast, runs across the sand and lies on death in the wave or the stopping of the escalators in the his towel. The warm breeze caresses his face, his shoulders, shopping centre – was not symbolically understood. The his chest… his body. He feels the morning sun. He closes answer to the question ‘What happened there?’ is missing. his eyes and stretches. He opens his eyes, looks at the open Those of us who know the story about the flood in the sea and spots something unusual. An enormous black wave Bible or Gecan’s project connecting Utrecht and Zagreb is approaching the shore. The wave consumes everything, were not there to experience it. That is the contradiction the sky is heavy and dark, and everything is gone. A few of experience. That is the central focus of Gecan’s work. minutes later, someone in the other end of the world, reads Cause, consequence and knowledge of a performed act are on the internet that a tsunami has caused a fatal disaster. not in harmony and they cannot be communicated. They He or she reads that there are no survivors on some islands. have to be materialized in representations which are com- That some islands are no longer there. prehensive to others, that is, someone who is outside an There is no contingency between his arrival on the art work and engaged in the transforming situation, that paradise island and the tsunami. There is no such thing is, the events underpinning Gecan’s artistic practice. as a causal chain of events which connects the wave and his stay on the island. The word ‘fate’ does not account for anything. A gap in the symbolic order has emerged: a 4. Cultural/Metaphysical Remarks: The Consumption of void, an absence that cannot be symbolized. The impossi- Forms of Life ble has happened and it escape the comprehension of the protagonist of the event. His experience is erased instantly. Contemporary culture features short circuits or corri- The ‘nothingness’ has been anchored in a fatal way. dors between art and culture. It features movements which The analogy between Tomo Savić Gecan’s work Un- transform art into culture and penetrate the world of its ef- titled (Utrecht – Zagreb) and this tragic narrative does fects. Those are the productions, multiplications, exchang- not lie in the degree of the tragic or the absurd but in the determining role of the ‘nothingness’ which, through its absence, that is, through its essential emptiness, controls 2007 Galerija PM¸ Julie Knifer: Power of something that happens here and now. emptiness What remains is culture as investigation and interpre- tation. Investigation leads to interpretation and interpre- The glazed areas that made it impossible tation leads to knowledge about what has happened and for visitors freely to circulate in the Museum why it has happened. However, the ‘why’ remains unan- of Contemporary Art in Zagreb during the swered in both cases. Was it the wish of the artist or fate exhibition Here Tomorrow, 2002, have been (or an act of God, the Devil, supernatural forces)? And, transformed into drinking glasses. whose knowledge is at stake? The knowledge of the sub-

es, consumptions, uses, applications as well as pleasures visual intervention; each is conceived merely as a trig- relating to the ‘appearance of meaning’ in art as an artefact ger for challenging mental determinism. Mental as cor- of the ordinary. These are the acts, deeds, behaviours or poreal. Gecan’s minimized visual, spatial or material interventions which incorporate culture into art and, vice world affects the body and the mind of the observer. versa, which incorporate art into the everyday procedures The observer discovers himself in the midst of an event and events of culture, that is, of human life. which he or she cannot grasp as a whole or determine This is the situation in which art finds itself in the age by meaning or experience. of confusion: today, at the beginning of the twenty first In addition, the observer finds himself or herself century, art lies beyond recognizable contextualization of caught in a trap of a missing cause and, as a conse- trends, styles, manners, movements, tendencies or vari- quence, becomes aware that this absence is the artwork ous media types. Contemporary art creates performances itself. The absence of a recognizable cause as an artwork within the chaotic, accelerated and incomprehensive art represents the phenomenalization of mental imagery phenomena in the open field of new media and perfor- within a specific cultural context. What happens to mance practices. the observer is something that escapes symbolization, Tomo Savić Gecan’s works, installations and perfor- something that occurs as an effluvial stage of the art- mances have been produced in this context but at the work20 or a situation pertaining to a relational21 aesthet- same time, they are incompatible with the regular pro- ics of contemporary art. ductions of art in the so-called age of culture. His pro- Tomo Savić Gecan is an artist who confronts the ob- ductions differ from the practices based on media repre- server with the void or an event appearing as a non-event, sentations and performed documents19 on or out of so- albeit through minimal phenomenalities which emerge cial and cultural conditions and circumstances. Gecan’s and unfold in the human world. Various interventions work is different through its displacement and absence, inside the institutions of contemporary art, culture and a totalizing minimalism and exception from the fictional society are performed in order to demonstrate that the context of ordinary life in which they appear as unex- zero degree is not an accomplished modernist reduction pected and intervening instruments. residing in the autonomy of artistic and aesthetical space. Tomo Savić Gecan is an artist who appears to go be- In contrast, the zero degree is an active subversive cultur- hind the screen of everyday reality. This ‘magic’ eeriness al act – a symptom – in which the body of the observer is intensified by the Duchamp-like unaesthetic rhetoric is structured and re-structured in new and unexpected and critical effect of the spatial situation on the specta- moves through environmental samples accommodated tor/accomplice/participant. What is it all about? by the artist in the institutions of culture and everyday In an age of cultural hegemony, Tomo Savić Gecan as life. Tomo Savić Gecan does this in museums, galleries, an artist deals with isolated effects, affectations, attrac- art magazines, shopping malls, parks, sport halls, city tions and consequences of the artificial world that com- walks, human situations and so on. poses our contemporary, daily, unnatural way of life. His artistic acts remain outside the autonomy of art although his starting point is the context of artistic and cultural in- symbolization intervention stitutions. He does not have a closed and defined space of artistic practice that has been legitimized because every cultural space belongs to the world as its media sample. The space of an intervention can be: performativity - a fictional-mental space inscribed in a gallery (Dunaújváros), - a behavioural space of motion indexed by the displaced metal railings installed on a road (Dubrovnik), - the space of a Sport Hall (Zagreb), abstract knowledge involvement in life - the space of elevators in a shopping mall (Zagreb), as event action in space and time - the space disturbed by the absence of shop windows (Brussels) - the space disappearing behind sliding walls (Ljubljana) However, each of his interventions is based on a symptom strong conceptual charge-effect and on the minimal at the zero degree

Miško Šuvaković: The Power of the Void, Speculative Realism... Ars Adriatica 5/2015. (193-202)

Tomo Savić Gecan’s art productions of an audience who attended an exhibition five years ago Philosophical Remarks: Contradictions of the Visible escape the basic common-sense practicality and rational- and the Invisible ity of human activity which is nowadays so closely con- nected with the spectacular which consist not only of Tomo Savić Gecan conceives his spatial and situation- a simple combination of images but includes the social al performances as the opposites to the spectacle. relationships between individuals which are mediated He starts from the premise that our age favours through images. The image disappears. It is not dema- events over visible relationships between different kinds terialized as in the conceptual art23 but converges with of objects. the minimal level of materiality the transience of which He demonstrates that the illusion of existence does escapes the scope of our attention. not come from the narrative or signifying power of the That level – the thin layer of the existence of reality – is image to imitate the real world or construct a potential the true medium of Gecan’s interventions in space, time, fictional one. He demonstrates that the material illusion human behaviour and in public institutions of culture and of an intervention comes from a minimal intervention- art. That thin layer of reality puts the subject in an awk- event in the world of the normal and the customary. The ward position. Something has happened and that which illusion prompted by his work comes from the almost has happened changed the world. The world is completely imperceptible changes of ordinary normal conditions, changed and, yet, it is as if nothing has happened. Causes that is, the relationships between objects, space, time and are invisible, connections are unmotivated, interventions human common-sense primary experience. are opaque. The dichotomy ‘has happened – has not hap- He subverts the ideology of the spectacle, rendering the pened’ is the one and only true dramaturgy of Gecan’s in- invisible as visible and omnipresent in the interest of capi- terventions aimed against the spectacle and hegemony of tal, power, public opinion, stability of the subject and so on. the visible, becoming, as is the case with all modern and Tomo Savić Gecan confronts the observer and through him postmodern spectacles, a kind of a cage, a ban or a barrier or her as an instrument which shows something or the ab- which situates human life in a captivity that is explained sence of something in an event, he confronts himself with and demonstrated in a rational way. visibility which vanishes through invisible changes, voids, deferrals or incongruities of causal chains. What is accom- plished through these actions is the loss of stability, normal- 2011 Witte de With “Melanchotopia” ity, or regularity of the normal world of the habitual and the ordinary. Human relationships become the effects of With each passenger who takes a particular incomplete, normal human lives which are sliding towards taxi in Rotterdam, the level of humidity in the the edge. Not a grand drama, but a minimal impalpable in- exhibition space changes. tervention in the world has made it endangered, rendering life questionable and social relationships fragile. Neverthe- less, what appears as fragility is not a grand narrative, but an 2011 Witte de With “Melanchotopia” almost imponderable change in situations, something that escapes the regular order of things. Every change in temperature in the city of Tomo Savić Gecan employs a tactic that is similar to Rotterdam causes one of the spaces in Witte de the one used by the directors of the X-Files22. Of course, With to open and close. the similarities are not obvious on the narrative level but in the mechanism which invokes a minimal intervention 2011 Witte de With “Melanchotopia” in the order of a symbolically situated reality which in- stantly and unexpectedly becomes the cause of questions, With every phone call to the office of the confusion, displacements and even disasters. Interven- curators of Melanchotopia, the light level in the tions he introduces into the order of the world do not exhibition space varies. look like interventions. The transformation with which Gecan intervenes belongs to the order below the thresh- 2011 Witte de With “Melanchotopia” old of expectations. No accumulation of meaning, a sum total of meaning or a demonstration of visible power can The temperature in the exhibition space is rationalize such an intervention. influenced by the movement of the people in Reducing the format of a magazine by 1 mm, chang- the Berlage Institute. ing the temperature by 1 degree or phoning the members

Tomo Savić Gecan works with that which cannot be and does not refer to that which a subject can rely on made into a spectacle but can be demonstrated as the when establishing relationships with other subjects. The sheer neutrality, a pure event, a loss, an inscription of the image has vanished in the event. All of that is almost void into the void: imperceptible, neutral and escapes our senses. This es- cape unfolds in the middle of a conspiracy theory. The The human being poses the day as such, and the day artist stages and performs his conspiracy theories. This thereby becomes the presence of the day – against escape is the essence of Tomo Savić Gecan’s art: it is at a background that is not a background of concrete the same time the performance of his art and its inten- night-time, but of possible absence of daytime, sity and through them it becomes an affect. where the night dwells, and vice versa moreover24. All this means that the vision of the world which is objectified through the spectacle is no longer credible Translated by Irena Šentevska

Bilješke

1 Graham Harman, “Object-Oriented Philosophy”, in Towards 15 Barbara Rose (ed), Art as Art; The Selected Writings of Ad Speculative Realism, Zero Books, Winchester UK, 2001. Reinhardt, University of California Press, Berkeley, 1991. 2 Michel Foucault, “The Thought of the Outside”, in Michel 16 Lucy R. Lippard, “Sol LeWitt: Nonvisual Structures”, in Changing Foucault: Ethics – Subjectivity and Truth, (ed. Paul Rabinow), - Essays in Art Criticism, A Dutton Paperback, New York, 1971, Penguin Books, London, 1997, pp. 149-154. p. 160. 3 Giles Deleuze, Difference and Repetitation, Columbia University 17 See, for example, the account of the Flood by the British author Press, New York, 1994, pp. 2. Julian Barnes (Chapter 1 – The Stowaway), in A History of the 4 Gilles Deleuze, “Immanence: A Life”, in Pure Immanence – World in 10½ Chapters, Alfred A. Knopf, New York, 1989. Essays on a Life, (ed. John Reichman), Zone Books, New York, 18 Production: Begane Grond, Utrecht. Realization: Ljudmila, 2001, pp. 25-33. Ljubljana & Poligon, Zagreb. 5 Giorgio Agamben, “The Lost Object”, in Stanzas – Word and 19 Boris Groys, “Art in the Age of Biopolitics: From Artwork to Phantasm in Western Culture, University of Minnesota Press, Art Documentation”, in Art Power, MIT Press, Cambridge MA, Minneapolis – London, 1993, pp. 19-21. 2008, pp. 53-65. 6 Abject Art, Witney Museum of American Art, New York, 1993; 20 Yves Michaud, L’art à l’état gazeux: essai sur le triomphe de Mladen Dolar, Das Unheimliche, Analecta, Ljubljana, 1994. l’esthétique, Hachette Littérature, 2004. See: Yves Michaud, 7 Jacques Derrida, L’écriture et la différence, Seuil, Paris, 1967. “Suvremena umjetnost u post-postu”, in Umjetnost u plinovitu stanju. Esej o trijumfu estetike, Ljevak, Zagreb, 2004, p. 80. 8 Exhibition Who by Fire #1, Institute of Contemporary Art, Dunaújváros, 1997. 21 Bourriaud, Nicolas, “Relational aesthetics and random materialism”, in Relational Aesthetics, Presses du réel, Paris, 9 Rosalind Krauss, “The Notes on the Index: Part 1” and “The 2002, pp. 18-24. Notes on the Index: Part 2”, in The Originality of the Avant- Garde and Other Modernist Myths, MIT Press, Cambridge MA, 22 The X-Files is a Peabody, Golden Globe and Emmy Award-winning London, 1985, pp. 196-209 and 210-219. American science-fiction television series, created by Chris Carter, which first aired in 1993 and ended in 2002. The show was a hit for 10 Rosalind Krauss: ‘By index I mean that type of sign which the Fox network and its characters and slogans (for example, ‘The arises as the physical manifestation of a cause, of which traces, Truth Is Out There’, ‘Trust No One’, ‘I Want to Believe’) became the imprints, and clues are examples’, pp. 211. touchstones of pop culture in the 1990s. Seen as a defining series of 11 Here Tomorrow, (ed. Roxana Marcoci), Museum of Contemporary its era, The X-Files tapped into the public mistrust of governments Art, Zagreb, 2002. and large institutions and embraced conspiracy theories and 12 Jacques Lacan, “The Subversion of the subject and the dialectic spirituality while focusing on efforts to uncover the existence of of desire in the Freudian unconscious”, in Écrit. A Selections, extraterrestrial life. The X-Files also spawned two theatrical movies Routledge, London, 2001, pp. 242. and one TV spin-off, The Lone Gunmen. 13 Marcel Duchamp, “Apropos of Readymades”, The Essential 23 Lucy R. Lippard, “Preface”, in Six Years: The Dematerialization Writings of Marcel Duchamp, (eds. Michel Sanouillet, Elmer of the Art Object from 1966 to 1972, Studio Vista, London, 1973, Peterson), Thames and Hudson, London, 1975, pp. 141-142. pp. 5-9. 14 Kazimir Malevich, The Non-Objective World, Paul Theobald, 24 Jacques Lacan, The Psychoses – Book 3: 1955-1956, W. W. Norton Chicago, 1959, p. 67. & Company, 1997, p. 141.

Miško Šuvaković: The Power of the Void, Speculative Realism... Ars Adriatica 5/2015. (193-202)

Najčitaniji članci istog autora / istih autora

Slični članci

Također možete Započni napredno pretraživanje sličnosti za ovaj članak.