Skip to content
Tijdschrift voor Adriatische kunstgeschiedenis Search

Evalutive Descriptions of Art

DOI 10.15291/ars.190

Download PDF

Vol. 6 (2016)

Open access

Article metrics

  • 3 412 Abstract views
  • 1 248 PDF downloads
  • 12 Downloads per day
  • 164 Downloads this month
  • Nataša Lah Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Rijeka, Department of History of Art lah@gmail.com Corresponding author
Taking into account the fact that, throughout history, certain artworks have been considered as “worth of watching” (according to the Greek etymon ἀξιοϑέατος / aksioteatos), preservation, or theorizing, while others were not, one is led to investigate the various types of evaluative descriptions. Those artworks that are more valuable than others, or simply valuable in themselves on the basis of rather specific features, have always represented the paradigmatic model for the evaluator, thus revealing the identitary nature of value as different from one epoch to another. Our aim has been to discern, with regard to this starting point, the way in which the process of evaluating artworks fits the general matrix of the universal theory of value, with its clearly distinguished levels of evaluation, beginning with value descriptions, continuing through the features of evaluation or abstract qualities of values extracted from these descriptions, and ending with value norms or systems of accepted generalizations in evaluation. Value standpoints in such an evaluation matrix represent dispositions or preferences in procedures, which reflect the norms or signifying concepts of the time. Corresponding procedures, or applications of the hierarchicized signification of artworks, are manifested in all known forms of artwork assessment: attribution, institutionalization, and setting of priorities in terms of exhibition, conservation, acquisition, restoration, and so on. Research in the history of European art-historical ideas has corroborated the hypothesis that, prior to the late 18th century, clear normative patterns were applied when it came to the evaluation of artworks. However, with the emergence of early Romanticism, this could no longer be done in the traditional way. Before the period in question, visual art was created (regardless of some stylistic discrepancies between individual authors) and classified according to well-defined thematic areas and functions. Such qualifications made it possible to distinguish clearly between major stylistic periods, creating the impression of development regardless of the later evaluative classifications of individual cycles in historical production thus understood. A comparison between the axiological matrix and the features of individual historical periods has revealed, on the one hand, a stable relationship between the functionally nomological features of artistic productions and the cultural instrumentalizations of art, and on the other a stable relationship between the overtly semantic conceptualizations in the epoch of modernism and the ostensibly structural mode of artistic expression. In the postmodern period, all that was once understood as the stylistic language of form, or the autonomy of the artefact, has been transformed in the evasive media multiplication of the postindustrial epoch into a whole series of reproductive languages, replicas, transfers, copies, or simulacra, and forced into a relationship of permanent detachment with regard to the “original” (source). Thus, instead of an artwork in context, the context itself is now presented as an artwork, structured all over again according to some of the possible principles in the theoretical choice of interpretation. The impossibility of defining precisely the boundaries of the medium, and its increasing dematerialization, have made it more difficult to apply universal evaluative criteria to a particular artwork, which has led to a conflict between cultural evaluation and the subjection of experience to the semantic functions of evaluations. Nevertheless, recent research on perception in the field of neuroscience has indicated that the sensory perception of the external world and the assignation of meaning to those perceptions indeed happen simultaneously, and that these processes cannot take place separated from one another. The conclusion shows that the modern evaluation conflicts are largely a consequence of an irreversible and entropic state of culture in the 21st century. We should therefore aim at a revision, not so much of the hitherto accepted and standardized values, but rather of the present systems of evaluation and the ensuing evaluative descriptions of art.
evaluation of art, value norms, conceptual attribution of meaning, instrumentalization of evaluation, evaluation conflicts, preferential descriptions
Sections
  1. Abstract
  2. Bilješke

The notion of value is considered in this paper through various forms, methods, and modes of historical evaluation in the field of visual arts, with the presumption that all types of preference with regard to a particular artwork or artworks, as compared to others in a similar group, are specific procedures of evaluation. The most frequent among these are value assessment, attribution, institutionalization, and setting of priorities in terms of exhibition, conservation, acquisition, or restoration. As such, they are a practical consequence of the system of defining and establishing hierarchies, as well as of normatively defined dispositions or value-relativized concepts. Using a historical overview of cultural paradigms, especially those that are clearly discernible against the art-historical matrix of major stylistic periods, the author has identified their characteristic value-related characteristics. The formal features of artworks appear to indicate best the sources of preferences or the institutionalized criteria of the commissioner, and subsequently the opposed evaluation criteria of an artist or a critic – an intermediary since the late 18th century. The period of early Romanticism marks the borderline between the traditional and modern patterns of evaluation, or rather articulates the idea of evaluative pluralism, closely related to a change in the understanding of the nature of the visual medium. The conclusion shows that the modern evaluation conflicts are largely a consequence of an irreversible and entropic state of culture in the 21st century. We should therefore aim at a revision, not so much of the hithertho accepted and standardized values, but rather of the present systems of evaluation and the ensuing evaluative descriptions of art.

Bilješke

1 Premda se uobičajeno prihvaća da je vrijednosni pojam „lijepe” 19 Svetlana Leontief Alpers (1936.) jedna je od najutjecajnijih umjetnosti relikt tradicionalne estetike, treba uzeti u obzir američkih povjesničara umjetnosti svoje generacije. Harvardska studije koje se bave naročitim statusom problema ljepote u profesorica, spisateljica i kritičarka specijalizirala se za interaktivnom odnosu kulture i umjetnosti kao što su: YVES nizozemsko slikarstvo zlatnog doba, a 1983. godine objavila MICHAUD, Umjetnost u plinovitom stanju. Esej o trijumfu zapaženu knjigu „The Art of Describing”. estetike, Zagreb, Naklada Ljevak, 2004.; ili ARTHUR C. DANTO, 20 SVETLANA LEONTIEF ALPERS, Ekphrasis and Aesthetic Nasilje nad ljepotom, Zagreb, MSU, 2007. Attitudes in Vasari’s Lives, Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld 2 Stvarni izbori podrazumijevaju želje i interese subjekta koji Institutes, 23 (1960), 190-215. vrednuje. 21 Vidjeti: ERNST H. GOMBRICH, Psihoanaliza i povijest 3 Poželjni izbori podrazumijevaju socijalno, znanstveno ili umjetnosti, Plastički znak, N. Miščević, M. Zinaić (ur.), Rijeka, kulturno artikulirane interese koje subjekt usvaja i u odlučivanju 1982., 165-190. primjenjuje. 22 O utjecaju političke ekonomije na prirodu umjetnosti vidjeti: 4 DANKO NIKOLIĆ, Ideasthesia and art, u: Digital Synesthesia. MARK BLAUG, The Economics of the Arts, London: Martin A Model for the Aesthetics of Digital Art. (ur. Katharina Robertson, 1976. Gsöllpointner), Berlin – Boston, 2016. (in press). 23 Formalist bečke škole povijesti umjetnosti Alois Riegl razloge 5 RALPH BARTON PERRY, General theory of Value. Its Meaning zbog kojih Winckelmanna treba smatrati prvim povjesničarom and Basic Principles Construed in Terms of Interest, Harvard umjetnosti, vidjeti će u njegovu, kako kaže – izrazitom nastojanju oko određivanja i isticanja zajedničkih crta pod koje University Press, 1967. se podvode manje bitni pojedinačni primjeri, odnosno zbog 6 Grčki izvornici prema: STJEPAN SENC (prir.), Grčko-hrvatski sposobnosti stvaranja veza među istovrsnom skupinom djela, rječnik, Zagreb, 1988. odnosno ‘pojmovnih cjelina’. Vidjeti: ALOIS RIEGL, Jedna 7 Pojam „matrica” ovdje se koristi za standardiziran oblik me- nova povijest umjetnosti, u: Bečka škola povijesti umjetnosti (ur. todološkog obrasca vrednovanja po kojem proces vrednovanja Snješka Knežević), Zagreb, 1999., 73-74. objedinjuje: vrijednosne opise (deskripcije), svojstva vrednova- 24 JOHANN JOACHIM WINCKELMANN, History of the Art of nja (apstrakcije ili ekstrahirane kvalitete iz deskripcija) vrijed- Antiquity, Los Angeles, 2006. nosne norme (generalizacije ili važenja) i vrijednosne stavove 25 GOTTHOLD EPHRAIM LESSING, Laokoon ili O granicama (dispozicije, odnosno stvarne i poželjne preferencije). slikarstva i poezije, Beograd, 1954. 8 NATAŠA LAH, How Style Became Famous and Irrelevant at the 26 Radi se o mramornoj skulpturi što je otkrivena u Rimu 1506. Same Time, Ars & Humanitas, 9 (2015), 215-230. god. (koju su, prema zapisu Plinija Starijeg, izradili kipari s 9 Slikarstvo, kiparstvo, arhitektura, primijenjena umjetnost itd. Rodosa Hagesandros, Athanodoros i Polydoros), poznatoj pod 10 Stilskim, formalnim, kontekstualnim, značenjskim (sadržajnim) nazivima Laookonova skupina, Smrt Laookona ili Laookon i itd. sinovi. Različiti su prijedlozi datacije izvornika (od 200. god. pr. n. e. do 70. god. n. e. veličina skulpture je 208 x 163 x 112 cm, a 11 JONATHAN BARNES (ur.), Complete Works of Aristotle, smještena je u vatikanskome muzeju Pio-Clementine. Volume 2, Princeton NJ, 1984.,1078, a36. 27 U to se rukama on ìz uzlova trga i trga / Oblit po tracima pjenom 12 Vidjeti: 1) LEONARDO DA VINCI, Vitruvijanski čovjek, cca i otrovom crnim, a k tome / Grozna vika ga stoji, k zvijezdama 1487., tuš i pero, 34.4 x 25.5 cm, Galerija Akademije, Venecija; dopire ona; / Takva je rika vola, kad zasječen on od oltara / Bježi 2) Ilustracije iz knjige markiza BERARDA GALIANIJA: i sjekiru zlo zabodenu iz vrata strese. Izvor: PUBLIJE VERGILIJE Arhitektura Marka Vitruvija Poliona, koja prikazuju ljudske MARON, Eneida, eLektire.skole.hr, Knjiga druga, Pjevanje proporcije, u odnosu na dijelove zidova i krovova (reprint drugo, stih 220, str. 31. napuljskog izdanja iz 1790. god., u izdanju Knjižnica Dedalo, 28 DENIS DIDEROT, Salons: Salon de 1761, 1765. Essai sur la Rim, 2005.). peinture, Charleston, 2010. 13 Vidjeti: Kuća njemačke umjetnosti u Münchenu, Prinzregenten- 29 JOACHIM VON SANDRART, Life of Rembrandt, Nürnberg, straße, otvorena 17. srpnja 1937. 1675. 14 Vidjeti: Kazalište Crvene armije (1929.) / Sovjetske vojske (od 30 EUGÈNE FROMENTIN, Oeuvres complètes, Paris, 1984. 1951.), Suvorov trg u Moskvi. 31 Vidjeti: JANET WOLFF, The Social Production of Art, New 15 PLOTIN, Eneade, Beograd, Književne novine, 1984. York, 1993. 16 PHILIP SCHAFF (ur.), The Complete Works of Saint Augustine, 32 Distinkcija prema: BERTRAND RUSSELL, Knowledge by Kindle Edition, [1649] Cic. Tusc. Quaest. i. 27. Acquaintance and Knowledge by Description, Proceedings of the 17 ST. THOMAS AQUINAS, The Summa Theologica, Christian Aristotelian Society (New Series) XI. (1910-11), 65-83. Classics, 1981. 33 Vidjeti: HRVOJE TURKOVIĆ, Radovan Ivančević (1931-2004) 18 GIORGIO VASARI, The Lives of the Artists, New York, 2008. – Pojmovni film prema Radovanu Ivančeviću, Hrvatski filmski

ljetopis, 39 (2004), 65-83; i HRVOJE TURKOVIĆ, Razumijevanje Media, Frame. Journal of Literary Studies (2010), 42-60; izraz perspektive, Zagreb, 2002. Gesamtkunstwerk prvi je put korišten u eseju „Aesthetik oder 34 NELSON GOODMAN, Ways of Worldmaking, Indianapolis, Lehre von der Weltanschauung und Kunst” njemačkog filozofa Hackett Publishing Company, 1978. Karla Friedricha Eusebiusa Trahndorffa (Berlin, 1827.), a potom u esejima njemačkog skladatelja Richarda Wagnera (sabrano u: 35 ROMAN INGARDEN, Erlebnis, Kunstwerk und Wert, Tübingen, Richard Wagner’s Prose Works, Vol. 1., London, 1895.). 1969. 47 Ideja je srodna Wagnerovu isticanju pozitivnih strana Eshilove 36 GEORGE DICKIE, Defining Art. The American Philosophical drame ili Nietzscheovoj sklonosti prema filozofiji predsokratovaca. Quarterly, 6 (1969). Jer, kritika Euripida u Wagnerovim esejima, nalik je Nietzscheovoj 37 Vidjeti: HANS BELTING, The End of the History of Art?, kritici Sokratove sintagme po kojoj „čula ne vide”. U biti kod History and Theory, 27(2), 1988., 188-199; i ARTHUR C. obojice se radilo o kritici kulturne paradigme koja semantičku DANTO, After the End of Art: Contemporary Art and the Pale of funkcija iskustva umjetničkog djela smatra nadređenom čulnoj. History, Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1997. 48 Interagirati – djelovati jedno na drugo, međusobno, uzajamno 38 Vidjeti: LINDA HUTCHEON, The Politics of Postmodernism, djelovati. London & New York Routledge, 1989. 49 NELSON GOODMAN, The Way the World Is, Review Of 39 Striktno se normirana estetika još uvijek nalazi u muzejsko Metaphysics, sv. 14 (1960), 48-56. galerijskim artikulacijama postava, najčešće u maniri arhitektonske tradicije funkcionalizma, zbog čega često dolazi do diskrepancije predstavljenog sadržaja i načina na koji se on predstavlja. 40 NELSON GOODMAN, Jezici umjetnosti, Zagreb, 2002., 217. 41 Pojam entropija (grč. ἐντροπή / čit. entrope, znač. obrt prema unutra) uveo je, njemački fizičar, osnivač termodinamike i kinetičke teorije plinova Rudolf Julius Εmanuel Klauzijus 1865. godine. Entropija predstavlja termodinamičku veličinu kojom se izražava stupanj degradacije energije nekoga fizikalnog sustava. Što je entropija veća, to je sposobnost sustava za rad manja, odnosno radi se o mjeri za nered nekoga sustava (sustav npr. atoma, molekula, iona neke tvari težit će tomu da postigne ili da zadrži takav raspored pri kojemu je entropija maksimalna, odnosno sposobnost za rad minimalna). Entropija je drugim riječima veličina stanja koja se može promatrati kao mjera za „vezanu” energiju nekog zatvorenoga materijalnog sustava, tj. za energiju koja se, nasuprot „slobodnoj”, više ne može pretvoriti u rad. Suprotan pojam je ektropija. Informatički, entropija označava mjeru za neodređenost informacije. U kontekstu rasprave o vrijednostima i vrednovanju koristi se istoznačno, ali u prenesenom smislu na stanje kulturnih kretanja u društvenoj zajednici. 42 NELSON GOODMAN, 2002, 190. 43 NELSON GOODMAN, 2002, 190, 34. 44 Za primjer možemo navesti instituciju pariškog Salona koja od 1862. godine uvodi praksu vrijednosne diskvalifikacije određene grupe umjetnika, čime ih društveno isključuje, na način da odbija na godišnjoj smotri izlagati njihove radove. 45 Za primjer možemo navesti jednu od aktivnosti Njemačke nacističke propagande s Josephom Goebbelsom na čelu, kada je organizirana izložba „Izopačene umjetnosti” u „Kući njemačke umjetnosti” i predstavljena brojnoj publici 19. srpnja 1937. godine, s ciljem da se umjetnička djela Ernsta Ludwiga Kirchnera, Emila Noldea, Georgea Grosza, Edvarda Muncha, Ernsta Barlacha, Ludwiga Meidnera, Franza Marca, Vasilija Kandinskog, Marca Chagalla, Otta Dixa, Paula Kleea i mnogih drugih umjetnika toga vremena, predstave javnosti ne samo kao bezvrijedna i izopačena već i kao društveno opasna. 46 Prema: KRISZTINA LAJOSI, Wagner and the (Re)mediation of Art: Gesamtkunstwerk and Nineteenth-Century Theories of

Nataša Lah: Vrijednosni opisi umjetnosti Ars Adriatica 6/2016. (253-264)

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Similar Articles

1-10 of 45

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.