The article addresses the issue of value present in Stanley Cavell’s philosophy of art. It focuses on Cavell as the representative of the Anglo-American ordinary language philosophy and his attitude towards the European tradition of post-structuralism as well as his attitude towards the problem of intersocial communication, rationality and poststructuralist antihumanism. The main argument is this: while post-structuralist theory of art deconstructs the notion of value and gives prominence to the notion of transgression, Cavell draws on the philosophy of ordinary language in the late works of Wittgenstein and manages to offer a materialistic and informalist reconstruction of the notion of artistic value.
Bilješke
1 ĐULIO KARLO ARGAN, Problemi moderne umetnosti (tekst 17 STANLEY CAVELL, Conditions Handsome and Unhandsome: predavanja održanog u Muzeju savremene umetnosti u Beogra- The Constitution of Emersonian Perfectionism, Chicago and du oktobra 1983.), Projeka(r)t, 11-15 (2001.), 26-28. London, 1990., 10. 2 GEORGE DICKIE, What is Art?: An Institutional Analysis, u: 18 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 17), 41. Art and Philosophy. Readings in Aesthetics (ed. W. E. Kennick), 19 Vidjeti: JÖRG VOLBERS, Crossing the bounds of sense: Cavell New York, 1979., 82-94. and Foucault, Contemporary Political Theory, 4 (2012.), 407-411. 3 RAYMOND WILLIAMS, Aesthetic, u: Keywords. A Vocabulary 20 MIŠEL FUKO, Istorija seksualnosti, knj. 3 (Staranje o sebi), of Culture and Society, New York, 1983., 31-32 Beograd, 1988., 79. 4 MARTIN JAY, Modernism and the Retreat from Form, u: Force 21 MIŠEL FUKO (bilj. 21), 77. Fields: Between Intellectual History and Cultural Critique, New 22 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 10), 3. York and London, 1993., 147-157; ŽORŽ BATAJ, Erotizam, Beograd, 2009. 23 MIŠEL FUKO, Arheologija znanja, Beograd i Sremski Karlovci, 1998. 5 MIŠKO ŠUVAKOVIĆ, Vrednost umetničkog dela, u: Pojmov- nik teorije umetnosti, Beograd, 2011., 779-780; vidjeti i: MAR- 24 MIŠEL FUKO (bilj. 21), 63. GARITA PETROVIĆ, Abjektno kao simptom avangarde, Beo- 25 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 17), 9. grad, 2010. 26 DŽUDIT BATLER, Potčinjavanje, otpor, preoznačavanje: 6 DAVID MACEY, Subject, u: Dictionary of Critical Theory, između Frojda i Fukoa, u: Psihički život moći. Teorije pokoravanja, London, 2001., 368-369. Beograd, 2012., 81. 7 LUC FERRY and ALAIN RENAUT, French Philosophy of the 27 DŽUDIT BATLER (bilj. 27), 82. Sixties. An Essay on Antihumanism, Boston, 1985., 17. 28 MICHEL FOUCAULT, Mesta, Delo, 5-7, (1990.), 277-286. 8 Vidjeti: PATRICK FERENCH, The Time of Theory: A History of 29 STEPHEN MULHALL (bilj. 14), 252. Tel Quel (1960-1983), Oxford, 1995. 30 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 17), 114. 9 ALEŠ ERJAVEC, Estetika dvadesetog veka: uvodne primedbe, 31 JÖRG VOLBERS (bilj. 20), 408. u: Figure u pokretu. Savremena zapadna estetika, filozofija i teorija umetnosti (ur. Aleš Erjavec i Miško Šuvaković), 32 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 17), 116. Beograd, 2011., 20. 33 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 17), 111. 10 STANLEY CAVELL, The Claim of Reason: Wittgenstein, Scepti- 34 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 17), 115. cism, Morality, and Tragedy, New York and Oxford, 1999., 25. 35 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 17), 103. 11 STANLEY BATES, Stanley Cavell and Ethics, u: Stanley Cavell, 36 STANLEY CAVELL, Pursuits of Happiness. The Hollywood (ed. Richard Eldridge), Cambridge, 2003., 20. Comedy of Remarriage, Cambridge and London, 2003. 12 STANLEY BATES (bilj. 11), 27. 37 LORA MALVI, Vizuelno zadovoljstvo i narativni film, Uvod u 13 STANLEY CAVELL, Aesthetic Problems of Modern Philosophy, feminističke teorije slike (ur. Branislava Anđelković), Beograd, u: Must We Mean What We Say?, Cambridge, 1998., 73-96. 2002., 189-200. 14 STEPHEN MULHALL, Stanley Cavell: Philosophy’s Recounting 38 STANLEY CAVELL (bilj. 37), 17-18. of the Ordinary, Oxford, 1998., 28. 39 STIVEN MALHOL, Stenli Kavel (1926.), Umetnost. Ključni 15 MIŠKO ŠUVAKOVIĆ, Diskursi norme: normativnost i estetika, savremeni mislioci (ur. Dirmid Kostelo i Džonatan Vikeri), u: Diskurzivna analiza, 2007., 122-132. Beograd, 2013., 163-166. 16 RALF VALDO EMERSON, Samodovoljnost, u: Ogledi, Beograd, 40 STIVEN MALHOL (bilj. 40), 165. 1983., 48-77. 41 ŽAK DERIDA, Istina u slikarstvu, Beograd, 2001.
Nikola Dedić: O vrijednosti: rekonstrukcija pojma nakon „smrti"... Ars Adriatica 5/2015. (211-222)