Skip to content
Internationale Zeitschrift für vergleichende Studien zur Geschichte der bildenden Künste, der sakralen und profanen Architektur, der städtebaulichen Entwicklung sowie der materiellen und immateriellen Kulturerbe-Überlieferung entlang der östlichen und westlichen Küsten des Adriatischen Meeres unter besonderer Berücksichtigung dalmatinischer, istrischer und venezianischer Verflechtungen vom frühen Mittelalter bis in die Gegenwart Search

Mediatory Function of Art Criticism Between History and Contemporaneity

DOI 10.15291/ars.455

Download PDF

Vol. 2 (2012)

Open access

Article metrics

  • 3 412 Abstract views
  • 1 248 PDF downloads
  • 12 Downloads per day
  • 164 Downloads this month
  • Nataša Lah Department of History of Art, Faculty of Philosophy, University of Rijeka nepostojeci156@gmail.com Corresponding author
The importance of questioning the mediatory role of art criticism was established by theory in the 1960s, when it began to erode the boundary between works of art and objects which are not art but which have been institutionalized as legitimate artworks by theoreticians, critics, museums, art galleries and a narrow but well-versed public audience. The postmodern period has further exacerbated this crisis by annulling the meaning and significance of all dominant theoretical tendencies. Such circumstances have shown that art criticism, by losing a firm theoretical and axiological stronghold, has neglected its fundamental function of initiating and articulating, theoretically interpreting and mediating current artistic practices and the contemporary life of the art world. Curatorial practices in these new circumstances have imposed thematic and evaluative orientation points on art criticism while institutional art theories have conversely encouraged the paradigm shift which has caused art criticism to lose its original purpose. Operating mostly in the sphere of the mass media, and in harmony with its function, art criticism has focused on documenting and bringing into the public arena those works which have already been evaluated in advance by conceptual curatorial practice. Given that such projects addressed mostly narrow professional circles and the activities of the relevant institutions, the wider cultural context of following and evaluating current artistic production was lost. Art criticism found itself in an unfavourable position, squeezed between the demands of its mother discipline (history of art) for a normative and established scholarly apparatus, and the counter-demands of the media within which it operates. Therefore, its mediatory role was neutralized.Recent professional activities across the world, including two large international conferences - What is Critique? held in New York in 2010, and the Art and Reality organized at Saint Petersburg in 2011 and focusing on aspects and trends in twentieth-century art criticism point to a re-awakening of interest in the revitalization of the purpose and meaning of art criticism.Our contribution to this subject orientates itself methodologically according to the postulates of the relativistic and moderately-analytical Anglo-Saxon aesthetics of Nelson Goodman, which argue for the influence of culture on reception. By adjusting to the (culturally conditioned) shift away from investigating the purpose, value and significance of a work of art towards the purpose, significance and value of the representation itself, the mediatory function of art criticism includes the reception of the cultural paradigm a work of art is presenting. The demand for a mediatory function for art criticism is also based on the consequences of the turbulent events of nineteenth-century art, when provocation against good taste as such caused a sudden expansion of mutually exclusive theoretical paradigms. In this sense, mediation also implies that art criticism is rooted in the history of the discipline. One of the pre-requisites for the understanding of such a suggestion is found in works such as Lionello Venturi’s History of Art Criticism and Oskar Bätschmann’s Einführung in die kunstgeschichtliche Hermeneutik: Die Auslegung von Bildern (Introduction to Art Historical Hermeneutics). In the case of Venturi we highlight in particular the tendency to link the art historical discipline and art criticism in such a way as to return art criticism to historical problems (understanding of the origin of a work of art), and history of art to forming judgements (the critical evaluation of a work of art). In the case of Bätschmann, we underline his analysis of the iconoclastic relationship of culture towards those types of artistic imagination for which no conditions for understanding are available. Both suggestions demonstrate the significance of art criticism’s mediatory role, on the one hand between history and contemporaneity, and on the other between art and audience.Such a role includes the question of competency in mediation, for which a static reception from the position of only one theoretical paradigm or one system of cultural values is not enough. Competency in mediation, apart from implying insight into the pluralism of social values in all their antinomies, and the pluralism of opinions and beliefs (in which ideologies always have a tendency to mobilize all interpretations directed to them), it also implies a critic’s ability to adjust to different methodologies. This does not support acting without a disciplinary focus but the possibility of adapting to a number of different central points within the discipline which may multiply or expire. In this case, competency in mediation is preceded by the detection of an artistic and cultural paradigm, but also by an authoritative application of theoretical and conceptual strongholds, varying from case to case, always recurring and always authentic.
art criticism, mediatory function, competence in mediation, paradigm shift, creation of understanding, active reception, disciplinary focus
Sections
  1. Abstract
  2. Literatura
  3. References

Potreba za naglašavanjem medijacijske funkcije umjetničke kritike temelji se na posljedicama turbulentnih promjena u novijoj povijesti umjetnosti. Prva od njih odnosi se na produkciju 19. stoljeća, kada je sintagma dobrog ukusa po sebi postala upitna, uslijed čega je došlo do širenja niza, međusobno nesvodivih, teorijskih paradigmi. Druga se velika promjena dogodila u šezdesetim godinama 20. stoljeća kada se izbrisala granica između umjetničkog djela i predmeta koji to nisu, što je pitanje smisla, značenja i vrijednosti umjetničkog djela usmjerilo pitanjima smisla, značenja i vrijednosti same reprezentacije. Kriza vrijednosti pojačala se kritikom autonomije umjetnosti i antiteorijskim stavovima u kulturi postmodernizma. Umjetnička je kritika u posljednjim desetljećima 20. stoljeća podlegla krizi, našavši svoje mjesto u masovnim medijima, podilazeći zahtjevima njihove društvene funkcije, dokumentirajući u prvom redu konceptualne kustoske prakse, i svojstvene im modele valorizacije. Mogućnost revitalizacije kritičkog diskursa nalazi se u aktiviranju njegove medijacijske funkcije, s jedne strane između povijesti i suvremenosti u čvršćem disciplinarnom okviru povijesti umjetnosti, a s druge između umjetnosti i publike, prilagodbom na promjenjive okvire kulturnih obrazaca. Preduvjet kompetentnoj medijaciji u tom je slučaju pronalaženje povijesno- umjetničke, ali i kulturne paradigme, kao i autorizacija primjene određenih teorijskih i konceptualnih uporišta na aktualna umjetnička postignuća koja inicira, artikulira, teorijski interpretira i posreduje.

Literatura

ARENDT, H., 2006. - Hannah Arendt, O zlu. Predavanje JENKS, C., 2002., 26-29 - Chris Jenks, Središnja uloga o nekim pitanjima moralne filozofije. Naklada Breza / oka u zapadnoj kulturi, u: Vizualna kultura (ur.) Chris Biblioteka Phos, Zagreb. Jenks, Jesenski i Turk, Zagreb, 11-45. BÄTSCHMANN, O., 2004. - Oskar Bätschmann, Uvod u KRUGER, B., 2010. - Barbara Kruger, Alexander povijesnoumjetničku hermeneutiku, Scarabeus, Zagreb. Alberro, Hal Foster, Martha Gever, Miwon Know, Carol BOREV, Y., 1985. - Yuri Borev, Aesthetics, Progress, Squiers, Barbara Kruger, Rizzoli, New York. Moskva. KUSPIT, D.B., 2010. - Donald Burton Kuspit, Art BRYSON, N., 1983., - Norman Bryson, Vision and criticism. Academic Dictionaries and Encyclopedias, Painting: The Logic of the Gaze. Macmillan, London. http://universalium.academic.ru/247410/art_criticism. (Retrieved 19/01/2012.). COSGROVE, D., 2008.- Denis Cosgrove, Kartiranje / LAZARSFELD, P. F., MERTON, R. K.., 1948. - Paul kartografija, u: Kulturna geografija, (ur.) David Atkinson, F. Lazarsfeld, Robert K. Merton, Mass Comunication, Peter Jackson, David Sibley, Neil Washbourne, Disput, Popular Taste, and Organized Social Action, u: The Zagreb, 55-62. Communication of Ideas, (ur.) Lyman Bryson, Harper, CUPCHIK, G. C., KEMP, S., 2000. - Gerald C. Cupchik, New York, 95-118. Stephen Kemp, The Aesthetics of Media Fare, u: Media LIND, M., 2011. - Maria Lind, Ten Fundamental entertainment: the psychology of its appeal (ur.) Dolf Questions of Curatin: No. IV - Why Mediate Art?, u Zillmann, Peter Vorder, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mousse Contenporary Art Magazin,e (ur.) Jens Hoffman, Inc., Mahwah, New Jersey, 249-277. Contrappunto S.R.L., Milano, 99-108. DICKIE,G.1977. - George Dickie, Introduction to MITCHEL, W., 2009. - William Mitchel, Ikonologija. Aesthetics: An Analytic Approach Oxford University Slika, tekst, ideologija. Antibarbarus, Zagreb. Press, New York. PAULI, G., 1921. - Gustav Pauli, Franz Marc. Der GADAMER, H. G., 1997. - Hans Georg Gadamer, Mandrill. In Kunsthalle, Kleine Fuhrer, Hamburg. Umjetnost slike i umjetnost riječi, u: Slika i riječ. Uvod u povjesnoumjetničku hermeneutiku, (ur.) Sonja Briski RORTY, R, 1995. - Richard Rorty, Kontingencija, ironija, Uzelac, Institut za povijest umjetnosti, Zagreb, 37-59. solidarnost, Naprijed, Zagreb. GADAMER, H. G., 2003. - Hans Georg Gadamer. SACHS-HOMBACH, K., 2006. - Klaus Sachs-Hombach, Umjetnost i mediji, u: Ogledi o filozofiji umjetnosti, AGM, Znanost o slici. Discipline, teme, metode, Antibarbarus, Zagreb, 211-235. Zagreb. GOODMAN, N., 2008. - Nelson Goodman, Načini SIEBERT, F. S., PETERSON, T., SCHRAMM, W., 1963. svjetotvorstva, Disput, Zagreb. - Fred S. Siebert, Theodore Peterson, Wilbur Schramm, Four Theories of the Press, University of Illinois Press., GOODMAN, N., 2002. - Nelson Goodman, Jezici Urbana, Chicago. umjetnosti. Pristup teoriji simbola. Kruzak, Zagreb. STRUKEN, M., CARTWRIGT, L., 2001. - Marita GRLIĆ, D., 1979. - Danko Grlić, Estetika IV. S onu Struken, Lisa Cartwrigt, Practices of Loocing Oxford stranu estetike. Naprijed, Zagreb. University Press, New York. HABERMAS, J., 1983.- Jürgen Habermas, Zahtjev ŠUVAKOVIĆ, M., 2005. - Miško Šuvaković, Pojmovnik hermeneutike za univerzalnošću, Zbornik teorije suvremene umjetnosti. Ghent: Horetzky, Vlees & Beton, tumačenja, Treći program, Beograd, 374-483. Zagreb. HÖRISCH, J., 2007. - Jochen Hörisch, Teorijska apoteka. VENTURI, L., 1963. - Lionello Venturi, Istorija Algoritam, Zagreb. umetničke kritike, Kultura, Beograd. HUTCHEON, L., 1988. - Linda Hutcheon, A Poetics of WHITE, H., 1999. - Hayden White, Historical Emplotment Postmodernism. Routledge, London - New York. and the Problem of Truth in Historical Representation, u: HUTCHEON, L., 19889 - Linda Hutcheon, The Politics Figural Realism: Studies in the Mimesis Effect, The Johns of Postmodernism. Routledge, London - New York. Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 27-42.

WOLF, J., 2005., - Janet Wolf, Društvena proizvodnja ZERNER, H., 1982. - Henri Zerner, Perspektive umjetnosti, u: Umjetničko djelo kao društvena činjenica, istraživanja, u: Plastički znak. Zbornik tekstova iz teorije (ur.) Ljiljana Kolešnik, Institut za povijest umjetnosti, vizualnih umjetnosti (ur.). Nenad Miščević, Milan Zagreb, 9-49. Zinaić, ICR, Rijeka, 39-49.

ARENDT, H., 2006. - Hannah Arendt, O zlu. Predavanje

o nekim pitanjima moralne filozofije. Naklada Breza /

Biblioteka Phos, Zagreb.

BÄTSCHMANN, O., 2004. - Oskar Bätschmann, Uvod u

povijesnoumjetničku hermeneutiku, Scarabeus, Zagreb.

BOREV, Y., 1985. - Yuri Borev, Aesthetics, Progress,

Moskva.

BRYSON, N., 1983., - Norman Bryson, Vision and

Painting: The Logic of the Gaze. Macmillan, London.

COSGROVE, D., 2008.- Denis Cosgrove, Kartiranje /

kartografija, u: Kulturna geografija, (ur.) David Atkinson,

Peter Jackson, David Sibley, Neil Washbourne, Disput,

Zagreb, 55-62.

CUPCHIK, G. C., KEMP, S., 2000. - Gerald C. Cupchik,

Stephen Kemp, The Aesthetics of Media Fare, u: Media

entertainment: the psychology of its appeal (ur.) Dolf

Zillmann, Peter Vorder, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,

Inc., Mahwah, New Jersey, 249-277.

DICKIE,G.1977. - George Dickie, Introduction to

Aesthetics: An Analytic Approach Oxford University

Press, New York.

GADAMER, H. G., 1997. - Hans Georg Gadamer,

Umjetnost slike i umjetnost riječi, u: Slika i riječ. Uvod

u povjesnoumjetničku hermeneutiku, (ur.) Sonja Briski

Uzelac, Institut za povijest umjetnosti, Zagreb, 37-59.

GADAMER, H. G., 2003. - Hans Georg Gadamer.

Umjetnost i mediji, u: Ogledi o filozofiji umjetnosti, AGM,

Zagreb, 211-235.

GOODMAN, N., 2008. - Nelson Goodman, Načini

svjetotvorstva, Disput, Zagreb.

GOODMAN, N., 2002. - Nelson Goodman, Jezici

umjetnosti. Pristup teoriji simbola. Kruzak, Zagreb.

GRLIĆ, D., 1979. - Danko Grlić, Estetika IV. S onu

stranu estetike. Naprijed, Zagreb.

HABERMAS, J., 1983.- Jürgen Habermas, Zahtjev

hermeneutike za univerzalnošću, Zbornik teorije

tumačenja, Treći program, Beograd, 374-483.

HÖRISCH, J., 2007. - Jochen Hörisch, Teorijska apoteka.

Algoritam, Zagreb.

HUTCHEON, L., 1988. - Linda Hutcheon, A Poetics of

Postmodernism. Routledge, London - New York.

HUTCHEON, L., 19889 - Linda Hutcheon, The Politics

of Postmodernism. Routledge, London - New York.

JENKS, C., 2002., 26-29 - Chris Jenks, Središnja uloga

oka u zapadnoj kulturi, u: Vizualna kultura (ur.) Chris

Jenks, Jesenski i Turk, Zagreb, 11-45.

KRUGER, B., 2010. - Barbara Kruger, Alexander

Alberro, Hal Foster, Martha Gever, Miwon Know, Carol

Squiers, Barbara Kruger, Rizzoli, New York.

KUSPIT, D.B., 2010. - Donald Burton Kuspit, Art

criticism. Academic Dictionaries and Encyclopedias,

http://universalium.academic.ru/247410/art_criticism.

(Retrieved 19/01/2012.).

LAZARSFELD, P. F., MERTON, R. K.., 1948. - Paul

F. Lazarsfeld, Robert K. Merton, Mass Comunication,

Popular Taste, and Organized Social Action, u: The

Communication of Ideas, (ur.) Lyman Bryson, Harper,

New York, 95-118.

LIND, M., 2011. - Maria Lind, Ten Fundamental

Questions of Curatin: No. IV - Why Mediate Art?, u

Mousse Contenporary Art Magazin,e (ur.) Jens Hoffman,

Contrappunto S.R.L., Milano, 99-108.

MITCHEL, W., 2009. - William Mitchel, Ikonologija.

Slika, tekst, ideologija. Antibarbarus, Zagreb.

PAULI, G., 1921. - Gustav Pauli, Franz Marc. Der

Mandrill. In Kunsthalle, Kleine Fuhrer, Hamburg.

RORTY, R, 1995. - Richard Rorty, Kontingencija, ironija,

solidarnost, Naprijed, Zagreb.

SACHS-HOMBACH, K., 2006. - Klaus Sachs-Hombach,

Znanost o slici. Discipline, teme, metode, Antibarbarus,

Zagreb.

SIEBERT, F. S., PETERSON, T., SCHRAMM, W., 1963.

- Fred S. Siebert, Theodore Peterson, Wilbur Schramm,

Four Theories of the Press, University of Illinois Press.,

Urbana, Chicago.

STRUKEN, M., CARTWRIGT, L., 2001. - Marita

Struken, Lisa Cartwrigt, Practices of Loocing Oxford

University Press, New York.

ŠUVAKOVIĆ, M., 2005. - Miško Šuvaković, Pojmovnik

suvremene umjetnosti. Ghent: Horetzky, Vlees & Beton,

Zagreb.

VENTURI, L., 1963. - Lionello Venturi, Istorija

umetničke kritike, Kultura, Beograd.

WHITE, H., 1999. - Hayden White, Historical Emplotment

and the Problem of Truth in Historical Representation, u:

Figural Realism: Studies in the Mimesis Effect, The Johns

Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 27-42.

WOLF, J., 2005., - Janet Wolf, Društvena proizvodnja

umjetnosti, u: Umjetničko djelo kao društvena činjenica,

(ur.) Ljiljana Kolešnik, Institut za povijest umjetnosti,

Zagreb, 9-49.

ZERNER, H., 1982. - Henri Zerner, Perspektive

istraživanja, u: Plastički znak. Zbornik tekstova iz teorije

vizualnih umjetnosti (ur.). Nenad Miščević, Milan

Zinaić, ICR, Rijeka, 39-49.

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Similar Articles

1-10 of 44

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.